I really don't get what your point is?

Also, I don't actually think I said that Dave Taylor was a poor. I said that I wouldn't want him at Wigan and if he was so great then why has a super league or NRL club not signed him.

By what reckoning? Greg bird played for Gold Coast for 6 years before signing for Catalan. Pretty sure he has played for Australia more than once too... I don't get what point you are trying to make?

<t>Yeah I am counting the year he was at Catalan and the year he was st Canberra, both of which are the last two years not the three clubs you mention before that.<br/> <br/> An Aussie international? He has played for them once. If he is so great why has he signed for a championship team. Surely if ...

Dave Taylor, seriously? There is a reason he has moved clubs pretty much every year.
Do you mean our players or our signings?

Really? You would want any of the players they have signed?

What and then let him go the next season?

This is quite ironic given a lot of people's views on past players returning ????

Maguire is a good coach and would probably do well at Warrington, he would certainly improve them.

I'm not sure him coming back to Wigan would be a good long term move. That's my opinion.

<t>Ok so point 1 I agree that not being the same team that played in and won the grand final isn't a true representation but surely you can't argue that a team would be significantly weaker. If that's the case surely that's the fault of the club for not recruiting correctly not the competition.<br/>...

Can you please tell me why you think that the WCC is a non event and doesn't mean anything please?
Are you saying that full time professionals aren't bothered about playing or winning this competition?

I know, not suggesting they or it shouldn't be celebrated as it is an achievement, they aren't champions though was my point.