Kevin Sinfield the best loose forward in Super League?Most overated in SL,Danny Mcguire missed too many games to be considered,and Dave Hodgson instead of Gareth Raynor?Fletcher should have been in second row and Ellis at 13

Withers will be a great signing,hes a good fullback and very experienced. Has anyone thought what happens if Ashton gets injured?. I still think Nobby may play Ashton at Centre anyway.

I think ill have a pint of whatever you had,must be strong stuff.

Im an old hooker,havent been arrested for it yet though.

I dont know whos idea Try Track is but it is pure nonsense,i cant understand what it is trying to tell us

<t>Cant agree,this SL has been below standard,yes its been more even because Leeds,Bradford Hull and of course us have all slipped. Hate to admit it but Stains have been miles ahead of everyone.To have teams of the standard of Salford and Warrington in the play offs just shows the poor standard this...

I cant understand why this guy gets so many rave reports,he is unfit.inconsistent and gives away far too many penalties. I hope Nobby is not interested in bringing him to Wigan.Anybody agree?

Manu is a good forward and i would love to see him at Wigan. Platt very impressive but with Withers and Ashton we dont need him

Dont want him,too slow and injury prone

I agree,i have seen him on Tele about 6 times this season,he goes in like a bull and has become a cult figure in Oz