Why I just think its an easy option to give set restarts even when its a 50/50 call...... its also always in favour of the attacking team..... time might change my mind though. Has the number of penalties decreased on average by the increase in set restarts? That is the important metric as in theor...

I think the Captains challenge is a great concept it is in place in Aus and the cricket also use it any comments here as to whether we should adopt it ?????? :roll: :roll: :roll: im all for it but still not 100% on the set restarts Why I just think its an easy option to give set restarts even when ...

ddtftf wrote: ↑Sun Apr 11, 2021 8:24 pm I think the Captains challenge is a great concept it is in place in Aus and the cricket also use it any comments here as to whether we should adopt it ??????

im all for it but still not 100% on the set restarts

pedro wrote: ↑Sun Apr 11, 2021 1:30 pm would be the same without it as it would be a penalty so still wouldnt have the ball

Yes i agree but i think the refs are more inclined to give a set restart than a penalty

Anybody watching this game can see how bad the new set restart rule can be....... the dragons had no ball this second half due to constant set restarts...... its totally spoiling the game as a spectacle...... i get that the dragons are holding on a bit too much but come on...... parra are like wire(...

Why would they want to be, They where awful They weren’t as bad as this lot IMO even tho I would get annoyed with them at times when they started to waffle on like two punters from down’t pub! 😂 Stevo wasn't too bad, He just got carried away a lot due to his passion for the game, Eddie (I'm a biase...

Nezza Faz wrote: ↑Wed Apr 07, 2021 10:32 pm Top of RL pundits/commentators, no question is Andrew Voss.

By a country mile pal...... he also gets excited by class players and plays..... he doesnt dwell on indiscipline like some commentators

Lockers coming out of retirement? Only abailable for the final though?........seriously please be a player

Surely it would make sense to play french on the wing for a week or two unless hes injured

I expect Clubb and Clark to play next week. How come? I would have thought for some match fitness and to let the soreness out of bumps and bruises. York have invested in older players just going down hill and loosing a bit of speed, but not necessarily skill so it would be a marker to see were the ...