Eddy P, a liability?

[cpwigan]

No not his Terry O'Connor v Gordon Tallis impression rather his hopeless decision making in defence that largely led to 2 Wire tries. Wires dominance in the 1st half owed much to his presence in the defensive line. Sorry but for an Aussie, Eddy is 'dumb' defensively!

We need Taylor OR dudson to replace him in the XVII IMO.

[wildbeast]

Not dudson PLEASE !!

[cpwigan]

Not dudson PLEASE !!

ANYBODY, even Hughes for 10/15 minutes at prop. Eddy is like a cross between an energizer bunny and a headless chicken. He is so eager to shoot out the line he makes rash and dumb decisions.

[TrueBlueWarrior]

Do you not think he had a great 15-20 mins just before his sin binning? To be fair Paul Wood threw 4 of his best and Eddy just stood there, class!!

[cpwigan]

Do you not think he had a great 15-20 mins just before his sin binning? To be fair Paul Wood threw 4 of his best and Eddy just stood there, class!!

He headless TBW. Go through that 1st half again and he was the biggest issue we had by far defensively.

[TrueBlueWarrior]

Do you not think he had a great 15-20 mins just before his sin binning? To be fair Paul Wood threw 4 of his best and Eddy just stood there, class!!

He headless TBW. Go through that 1st half again and he was the biggest issue we had by far defensively.

I wasn't disagreeing with anything you said just making a point about the start of his second half!!

[jobo]

Do you not think he had a great 15-20 mins just before his sin binning? To be fair Paul Wood threw 4 of his best and Eddy just stood there, class!!

He headless TBW. Go through that 1st half again and he was the biggest issue we had by far defensively.

At the game he looked outstanding at times. Not been his biggest fan so far but along with Gelling he does seem to be coming on as an asset rather than liability.

[cpwigan]

Jobo, he looks much better than he is owing to his frantic headless chicken approach BUT defensive brain is none existent. He will cost us more than win us games!

[ian.birchall]

No not his Terry O'Connor v Gordon Tallis impression rather his hopeless decision making in defence that largely led to 2 Wire tries. Wires dominance in the 1st half owed much to his presence in the defensive line. Sorry but for an Aussie, Eddy is 'dumb' defensively!

We need Taylor OR dudson to replace him in the XVII IMO.

Don't like to say this CPW but I agree. For the second week running we went off the ball when Wane changed his entire front row, leave Flower on for goodness sake until he begins to flag after about 60 minutes. Unfortunately I'm afraid he might not have that decision to make next week for Micky Mac, the way Powell has played the last two weeks makes me think we should get Tomkin's Jnr back on the pitch when MM is banned.

[TrueBlueWarrior]

No not his Terry O'Connor v Gordon Tallis impression rather his hopeless decision making in defence that largely led to 2 Wire tries. Wires dominance in the 1st half owed much to his presence in the defensive line. Sorry but for an Aussie, Eddy is 'dumb' defensively!

We need Taylor OR dudson to replace him in the XVII IMO.

Don't like to say this CPW but I agree. For the second week running we went off the ball when Wane changed his entire front row, leave Flower on for goodness sake until he begins to flag after about 60 minutes. Unfortunately I'm afraid he might not have that decision to make next week for Micky Mac, the way Powell has played the last two weeks makes me think we should get Tomkin's Jnr back on the pitch when MM is banned.

We miss Williams!!