Bateman

[Charriots Offiah]

Interesting to hear James Graham’s comments last night that, in his view, Batty’s selection for England is a must.

[josie andrews]

Interesting to hear James Graham’s comments last night that, in his view, Batty’s selection for England is a must.

Moved to General Forum

[Charriots Offiah]

Fair enough Josie. I posted it in the Wigan section in response to the recent thread on John. It’s funny how the top pros and coaches rate him so highly but not some of our fans.

[josie andrews]

Fair enough Josie. I posted it in the Wigan section in response to the recent thread on John. It’s funny how the top pros and coaches rate him so highly but not some of our fans.

He hasn’t played to his potential for us since he came back apart from the odd piece. And probably a lot of Wigan fans rate this performance for us as not worthy of marquee money.

[Charriots Offiah]

Fair enough Josie. I posted it in the Wigan section in response to the recent thread on John. It’s funny how the top pros and coaches rate him so highly but not some of our fans.

He hasn’t played to his potential for us since he came back apart from the odd piece. And probably a lot of Wigan fans rate this performance for us as not worthy of marquee money.

He's a big game player who rarely has a bad game, but I understand your point of view. He was good tonight.

[fozzieskem]

He's not the player he was before he went down under yet I think wigan are a better side with him in it,so it must be a style change he's under gone may be I'm not sure but I'd sooner he play than not.

More worrying is unless Lenegan has invested in an age reducing potion company the bigger problem wigan have is Liam Farrell getting older now he is a player who's missed every game he doesn't play how do you replace him

[Charriots Offiah]

He's not the player he was before he went down under yet I think wigan are a better side with him in it,so it must be a style change he's under gone may be I'm not sure but I'd sooner he play than not.

More worrying is unless Lenegan has invested in an age reducing potion company the bigger problem wigan have is Liam Farrell getting older now he is a player who's missed every game he doesn't play how do you replace him

The short answer is you don’t.

[fozzieskem]

He's not the player he was before he went down under yet I think wigan are a better side with him in it,so it must be a style change he's under gone may be I'm not sure but I'd sooner he play than not.

More worrying is unless Lenegan has invested in an age reducing potion company the bigger problem wigan have is Liam Farrell getting older now he is a player who's missed every game he doesn't play how do you replace him

The short answer is you don’t.

Exactly I fear the Perl is going to be harder to replace than Lockers was

[moto748]

Can't we just knit another one?

[Barney841]

Fair enough Josie. I posted it in the Wigan section in response to the recent thread on John. It’s funny how the top pros and coaches rate him so highly but not some of our fans.

He hasn’t played to his potential for us since he came back apart from the odd piece. And probably a lot of Wigan fans rate this performance for us as not worthy of marquee money.

I agree.
Although Batty doesn’t seem the player he was, he’s still a decent player.
The gripe is with most Wigan fans is the marquee money, you feel like he should be a stand out performance most games but he’s just more solid than anything