Who is right?

[cpwigan]

Brian Noble that the defeat to Celtic was the turning point to our season or Phil Clarke that the injury to Tim Smith enabling Sam Tomkins to start/finish games ?

[weststand-rich]

All three of you - Phil Clarke, Brian Noble and you Morph!!

[GeoffN]

Brian Noble that the defeat to Celtic was the turning point to our season or Phil Clarke that the injury to Tim Smith enabling Sam Tomkins to start/finish games ?

I've been saying for ages that Smith's injury was the best thing that could have happened for us, even if it does result in BN keeping his job!

[jackoh]

I don`t believe it was the loss at Bridgend thats changed our season , but the loss of Hock ,Smith ,Lockers ,Macca and Bailey has meant we`ve brought younger players in who`ve played their socks off for Wigan .
WE`ve had the talent there all the time but Noble hasn`t seen it.

[Panchitta Marra]

I don`t believe it was the loss at Bridgend thats changed our season , but the loss of Hock ,Smith ,Lockers ,Macca and Bailey has meant we`ve brought younger players in who`ve played their socks off for Wigan .
WE`ve had the talent there all the time but Noble hasn`t seen it.

Well true Jackoh.
Giving the young talent a chance has proven what they can do.
I still think though, that a fit again Lockers & MM would be an asset to the match squad.

[OAMJSONA]

I don`t believe it was the loss at Bridgend thats changed our season , but the loss of Hock ,Smith ,Lockers ,Macca and Bailey has meant we`ve brought younger players in who`ve played their socks off for Wigan .
WE`ve had the talent there all the time but Noble hasn`t seen it.

Well true Jackoh.
Giving the young talent a chance has proven what they can do.
I still think though, that a fit again Lockers & MM would be an asset to the match squad.

youth is the future

the future is now

[jobo]

Phil Clarke has it bob on. The team at the moment has been forced on Noble, it isn't one he would have picked had circumstances been different.
I still think Nobby has had his time and should go at the end of the season, along with Vievers.