fit to wear the shirt

[cockney]

Ive supported wigan,and the greatest game for many years,and would like to know if you all are as thrilled as me,for the first time in years I believe that win or lose we have got a team deserving the name wigan,and as we all know only gods deserve to play for us,but as a bit of devilment,would like to know ,what recent players didnt deserve to wear the shirt, what is the top ten who should never have been within ten miles of the dw,or even the jjb or central park,and who was the worst player in recent years to play for wigan or ever?footnote:if they wore the shirt i supported them all,but would like your opinion

[ancientnloyal]

Richie Mathers, Dennis Moron, David Vaealiki in recent memory

Paul Koloi is my obsession.

Singings like Oliver Wilkes and Jordan James were not 'wigan' players...

[TonyH]

All these positive comments about our team etc are coming out this year cause we are doing well but if you remember we had the same team last year so it's really a credit to the Coaching Staff and how the Players have lifted themselves from previous years short comings.

Best player to pull on a Wigan shirt in my book, Kris Radlinski, talk about taking one for the team!

Worst: Richie 'I love me who do you love' Mathers

[ian.birchall]

Richie Mathers, Dennis Moron, David Vaealiki in recent memory

Paul Koloi is my obsession.

Singings like Oliver Wilkes and Jordan James were not 'wigan' players...

Wilkes I agree with, another of TAPs' signings but not so quick to write off James, another of TAPs signings of course, remember he joined us from being a part time player with Swinton and wasn't given long enough to get up to super league fitness levels but whilst he was with us he could score tries and dish out the biffo as well. I think that under Madge he would have made it.

[gpartin]

Doc Murray x10

[doc]

I agree that Jordan James could have been a decent player given the right coaching.

He only came in to the game later in life and was playing at a much lower level until we signed him. Despite this he always appeared to put in 100% and scored some important tries. His efforts put some of the bigger names in the squad at the time to shame.

[old_trafford_or_bust]

Desi Williams was just awful!

[ddtftf]

Ritchie Mathers NO CONTEST

[pedro]

Doc Murray made Mathers look like a world beater

[East Stand Al]

Doc Murray. Aaaaaaaaaaargh. Jimmy Birts slightly worse.