RATE THE PLAYERS SO FAR THIS YEAR!

[turf]

I just thought that you would like to rate the players so far this season:

Ashton - Very young and inexperienced, but he is learning.

Calderwood - I bet he wishes he'd stayed at Leeds now.

Richards - I heard that he has scored a couple of good tries, and tries hard

Vaealiki - I don't think he's been as bad as last year.

Dallas - I think that about half the fans feel sorry for this guy this year, always wears his heart on his sleeve, and along with Godwin is the most dependable player on the team!

Orr - ALWAY runs his socks off!! Yet some people always think that he is to blame for everything.

Moran - What a useless piece of Rubbish! Can't pass, can't kick, can't tackle and can create sod all!!!

Logan - Possibly a great signing, but he just needs to get back on the field.

Higham - Nothing special.

Feca - Made some very good impact.

Tickle - Very very lazy, especially this year.

Fletcher - Made some punishing runs.

O'Loughin - Puts in good passes, is good at catching awkward passes and puts in some good tackles in defence.

The rest of em.....

Hansen - Looked good last year. Does always give 100% but looks a bit risky in defence at times.

Hargreaves - Keeps his legs pumping, and always puts in 100%. He needs to bulk up a bit first though.

Prescott - How skinny is he?!? Never a prop forward in a million years!!

Seu Seu - Is playing miles better than last year.

Godwin - Along with Dallas, is probably our best player. I would rather have Godwin than Higham.

Tompkins - He's been ok, when he's been on the pitch.

Kev Brown - I would rather us play with 12 men than have him on the pitch. He gets trampled allover!

What do you lot think?

[heydude]

agree with most of it only don't agree with DV can't see how crap can get any better totally useless last season and carry on being the same this season so really you can at least called him consistent.

[First Try Tickle]

Sorry, you seem to have Orr and Moran's descriptions the wrong way round.

Plus you say you've heard Richards has scored a couple of tries...HEARD not seen.

Are you calling Moran off what you've heard.

[ince warrior]

Ashton - Brilliant for his age, one for the future

Calderwood - Improved over the last few games after his disaster against Hudds in the testimonial

Richards - OK, but hasn't been tackling and can be a bit greedy at times

Vaealiki - Pretty lazy, seems to go missing in matches

Dallas - Brilliant, but hasn't had any proper service

Orr - Crap passing, crap tackling

Moran - Good player, but his kicking hasn't been up to scratch

Logan - A beast, a good prop but lethal in Walkabout

Higham - Hasn't been as creative as he was in the tri nations

Feca - What a signing

Tickle - Doesn't look like he's trying, maybe sulking after losing the no. 11 shirt to Hock

Fletcher - Played well while fit

O'Loughin - Not captain material but a decent loose forward

The rest of em.....

Hansen - Looked decent

Hargreaves - Not that big for a prop but has played well when on the field

Prescott - If he bulks up, he'll be class

Seu Seu - Playing well, and has made maximum impact when partnered with Feka

Godwin - Easily our best hooker, and puts himself about on the field

Tompkins - Not done owt wrong

Kev Brown - If I started about how crap he was, I'd be here all day

[superleague]

ince warrior posted:
Orr - crap tackling

if theres one thing he can do that is tackle
:conf: