Page 2 of 6
Re: Apology to Fielden
Posted: Sat Aug 11, 2007 7:47 pm
by Nicola#Warriors
Bear posted:
Nicola#Warriors posted:
he definatley is getting back to his best , even if it doesn't come by the end of this season, i reckon next yr he'll be on top form
Why because hes had one good run as soon as he came on... jesus he still diddnt make any yards for a world class prop he needs to be like Betts Handing off
one good run?
he made quite a few
and no he isn't quite there yet but there was a huge improvement which to me means that he is on his way to his best
Re: Apology to Fielden
Posted: Sat Aug 11, 2007 7:53 pm
by cpwigan
I saw no improvement in his running with the ball in hand. He does not lack the effort BUT his technique is woeful. IIRC he got smashed once too.
Re: Apology to Fielden
Posted: Sat Aug 11, 2007 7:55 pm
by Bear
Abserloutly awfull!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Re: Apology to Fielden
Posted: Sat Aug 11, 2007 7:59 pm
by Nicola#Warriors
no way was he awful, far from it, and i also see no point in singling out 1 player for specific criticism, when it's the team's display that should be critisised the most
he is definately improving, and to be honest, he was never the worst player in our squad to begin with
Re: Apology to Fielden
Posted: Sat Aug 11, 2007 8:03 pm
by Bear
Nicola#Warriors posted:
he was never the worst player in our squad to begin with
No but God knows how hes got so bad
Ok yeah he took a few strong drives up were he made a massive 2 yards
Re: Apology to Fielden
Posted: Sat Aug 11, 2007 8:05 pm
by damien morrissey
Nicola#Warriors posted:
no way was he awful, far from it, and i also see no point in singling out 1 player for specific criticism, when it's the team's display that should be critisised the most
he is definately improving, and to be honest, he was never the worst player in our squad to begin with
That covers it me thinks.
Re: Apology to Fielden
Posted: Sat Aug 11, 2007 8:07 pm
by Nicola#Warriors
Bear posted:
Nicola#Warriors posted:
he was never the worst player in our squad to begin with
No but God knows how hes got so bad
Ok yeah he took a few strong drives up were he made a massive 2 yards
did u re watch the game?
because i think he made more than "2 yards"
feka may make more yards than him but how many does he make per game?
5/6?
at least stu plays for the majority of the match
if he's THAT bad then why does noble play him every week then?
because he's not that bad at all
Re: Apology to Fielden
Posted: Sat Aug 11, 2007 8:11 pm
by Nicola#Warriors
Flinny posted:
Yeah mate your right. I think it's taken him a while to get over a disapointing tri nations but he is getting better week by week. Come on Stu keep improving, we're going to need you at your best !!
didn't see this comment before
yepp and it's encouragement like this that will help him to improve!
Re: Apology to Fielden
Posted: Sat Aug 11, 2007 8:13 pm
by Bear
It was the first time stu had been dropped to bench in his entire carrer ... he isnt the worlds best prop now... Not a patch on the likes of Civonacina, Feka, and Ruban Wiki.
Feka makes more line breaks than him. And yes i did watch the game and saw him get pushed back a few times as well... I know im being quite hard on him here. But at the end of the day im stating my views
Re: Apology to Fielden
Posted: Sat Aug 11, 2007 8:17 pm
by Nicola#Warriors
Bear posted:
It was the first time stu had been dropped to bench in his entire carrer ... he isnt the worlds best prop now... Not a patch on the likes of Civonacina, Feka, and Ruban Wiki.
Feka makes more line breaks than him. And yes i did watch the game and saw him get pushed back a few times as well... I know im being quite hard on him here. But at the end of the day im stating my views
no he isn't the best anymore and i think he more than anyone knows that
fair enough, your views n all but these are mine
so we shall just have to see how he plays on sat!
