Page 2 of 2
Re: So this is the possible ru...
Posted: Fri Jun 13, 2008 2:12 pm
by The Eclipse
Goulding instead of Phelps hopefully
Re: So this is the possible ru...
Posted: Fri Jun 13, 2008 5:52 pm
by mike binder
old hooker wrote:I really hope Nobby has enough sense to leave Barrett at 6. He is our best player by a mile and no one should ever play their most potent weapon out of position.Smith may well be a great signing for us but to just put him straight in the side would be mad. It will be probably be a few weeks before hes fit,after all he,s only been surfing and working with a carpenter in recent times,apart of course from trying to drink Australia dry.
thing is 6 and 13 play very similar roles ,dont think putting trent at 13 will lose any of his bossing the game skill
Re: So this is the possible ru...
Posted: Fri Jun 13, 2008 7:19 pm
by butt monkey
The Eclipse wrote:Goulding instead of Phelps hopefully
Only if his defence is better and learns to pass!
Re: So this is the possible ru...
Posted: Fri Jun 13, 2008 8:25 pm
by butt monkey
cherry.pie wrote:butt monkey wrote:The Eclipse wrote:Goulding instead of Phelps hopefully
Only if his defence is better and learns to pass!
Goulding actually defended really well against Leeds and kept us in the game at one point. It was one of his better games this season and he shouldn't be dropped after that for some Aussie reject.
He might pass a little more if Bailey passed the ball and didn't close up all the space down the right by keeping hold of the ball for too long. Tomkins is much better down that side.
I suppose you also classed Trent Barrett as a reject too?
or how about Brett Dallas????
As for having one good game - even Thomas Coyle "had that" and look where he's playing now!
Re: So this is the possible ru...
Posted: Sat Jun 14, 2008 2:23 pm
by old hooker
mike binder wrote:old hooker wrote:I really hope Nobby has enough sense to leave Barrett at 6. He is our best player by a mile and no one should ever play their most potent weapon out of position.Smith may well be a great signing for us but to just put him straight in the side would be mad. It will be probably be a few weeks before hes fit,after all he,s only been surfing and working with a carpenter in recent times,apart of course from trying to drink Australia dry.
thing is 6 and 13 play very similar roles ,dont think putting trent at 13 will lose any of his bossing the game skill