Phelps New contract would you?

[butt monkey]

I think evryone agrees. Makes a change, doesn't it!

Doesn't make for an "entertaining" thread though does it?

[cpwigan]

I think we should wait and see and judge him in 4 or more games. Played too many games on the wing. I want to see him more at centre, fullback etc and can he fight? Not keen on the pushy stuff, cold eyed stare and kapow, drop him dead!






Just for you BM but I do.

[Bear]

I would definatly give him another contract, fast player and he does a good job. Shows 100% effort every game

[KOOCH]

Confident player not afraid to go for the line.Good positional play and backs up well.Versatile.Give him the contract IL before one of our rivals do.

[old hooker]

i would like to see him play a few games at full back as Mathers does not seem to be the answer and Pats attacking potential is of more use on the wing.

[GeoffN]

i would like to see him play a few games at full back as Mathers does not seem to be the answer and Pats attacking potential is of more use on the wing.

I agree, and both he and IL seem to think it's his preferred position. Noble, on the other hand, apparently doesn't.

[cpwigan]

To be honest we learned far more IMO from one game at centre than several on the wing. Had he not played centre I would not have been impressed personally.

[doc]

Will be a good squad player in the Panapa mold.

[neilbass]

Proved himself again last night for me - a great break.

He's strong, fast & powerful - and versatile. Great player to have in the squad to cover injuries etc.

[jackoh]

I agree to keeping him , I`ld like to see him at full back so Mathers can sign for Batley .