Who would you keep, who would you show the door?

[mackie1981]

Keep
Amos Roberts
Darrell Goulding
George Carmont
Pat Richards
Thomas Leuluai
Stuart Fielden
Iafeta Paleaaesina
Gareth Hock
Sean O'Loughlin
Joel Tomkins
Harrison Hansen
Michael McIlorum
Paul Prescott
Eamon O'Carroll
Sam Tomkins
Mark Flanagan
Shaun Ainscough


Get Rid of
Cameron Phelps (Taking up a qouta spot only average)
Andy Coley ( Not big enough for a prop)
Richard Mathers ( No explanation needed a liability)
Phil Bailey ( Same as Phelps)

Not sure(Not Fully Fit will reserve judgment till they are)
Mark Riddell
Tim Smith
Karl Pryce

Not Sure (Not seen them play so unfair to say either way)
Ben Davies
Chris Tuson
Ian Thornley
Liam Farrell
Lee Mossop

[cpwigan]

I do not agree with his selection but he is as entitled as anybody to express them.

oh i agree, but i'm entitled to question it. i was just wondering what the reasons were, as well as being in mild shock

Very much. It was just the secondary comment not by you was more negative and I did not want to see a poster criticised for having a view. Everybody is entitled to a view and for others to agree / disagree in a reasoned manner. Healthy debate.

[platt-warrior]

For goodness sake stop acting like a pompous Jimmy Edwards
like headmaster,lecturing everybody.My thread was posted in jest,loosten-up a bit.

[OAMJSONA]

noble, noble,noble,noble,noble,noble,noble,noble,noble,noble

coley.
mathers,
bailey,
phelps,


forshaw
vievers


LENEGAN

[ancientnloyal]

Keep:

Amos Roberts
Darrell Goulding
George Carmont
Pat Richards
Thomas Leuluai
Iafeta Paleaaesina
Gareth Hock
Sean O'Loughlin
Joel Tomkins
Harrison Hansen
Michael McIlorum
Paul Prescott
Karl Pryce
Eamon O'Carroll
Lee Mossop
Sam Tomkins
Liam Farrell
Shaun Ainscough
Ben Davies
Chris Tuson
Ian Thornley

Leave:
Richard Mathers
Tim Smith
Stuart Fielden
Mark Riddell
Phil Bailey
Andy Coley
Cameron Phelps

Im prepared to give Amos a chance, he has a good record even though he's 29.

[ajsefc]

Richard Mathers - Get Rid, no confidence which is vital for a FB
Amos Roberts - Jury very much out still
Darrell Goulding - Excellent prospect, slightly too selfish
George Carmont - Needs to find form of last year
Pat Richards - KEEP - OUSTANDING
Tim Smith - Would love to see him in our team when he's actually allowed to play expansive rugby at number 7
Thomas Leuluai - Switch to Hooker
Stuart Fielden - Keep, if we can get more out of him
Mark Riddell - Keep as interchange number 9
Iafeta Paleaaesina - Outstanding impact Prop
Gareth Hock - One of few potential world Class players we have, needs catching practice though
Phil Bailey - Feel a bit harsh but send him home, he's an average perfomer and we are very talented in the 2nd row
Sean O'Loughlin - Keep - give Captaincy to Someone else though
Joel Tomkins - Our best player in the future IMO - Oustanding prospect
Andy Coley - Bye Bye - thought he was very good for first 10 rounds lst year but slowly declined ever since
Harrison Hansen - Superb - must keep
Michael McIlorum - Not good enough and been aound the first team for 3 years, get rid
Paul Prescott - Keep - Outstanding prospect - needs to stay injury free
Karl Pryce - Keep, we have seen glimpses of what a player we could have on Friday when he's only 60% fit
Cameron Phelps - Not sure very good utility player but he should be an interchange player to cover several areas IMO
Eamon O'Carroll - Jury still out but if he continues to improve he's a keeper
Lee Mossop - Oustanding potential - must keep
Sam Tomkins - As above but maybe even more potential
Mark Flanagan - Can't comment but heard mixed reviews
Liam Farrell - As above
Shaun Ainscough - If Friday is anything to go by - definite 1st teamer
Ben Davies - Definite keeper
Chris Tuson - Not good enough, will be a good solid player but not Wigan standard
Ian Thornley - Can't comment

[mike binder]

cant beleive after 3 games were having this conversation ,god im thinking of a transfer ro RFL fans

[ancientnloyal]

cant beleive after 3 games were having this conversation ,god im thinking of a transfer ro RFL fans

Our club's situation isnt THAT bad Mike.

[mike binder]

no its not,theres a team in there trying to get out

[ancientnloyal]

Glad you've stayed at wwf.com :inlo: