Alternate Season Awards

[fozzieskem]

Most Improved Player: Navarrete
Best Newbie: Partington
Surprise of the year: Wane Leaving
Low point of the year: Sam Leaving / Hardaker arriving
Best moment (regular season): Cats Away
Worst game: Wire Away in Cup
Best Young Player: Mullen
Try of the season: Manfredi's 2nd on Saturday
Lam, please don’t change...Defence
Lam, please change...Attack

Just swapped Hamlin out for Ollie Partington who does look rather promising

[medlocke]

Best moment: Finally getting rid of Joel Tomkins

[josie andrews]

Most Improved Player: Navarrete
Best Newbie: Hamlin
Surprise of the year: Wane Leaving
Low point of the year: Joel T
Best moment (regular season): Smashing Leeds
Worst game: either St Helens Losses
Best Young Player: Davies (if he still counts as young)
Try of the season: Manfredi's 2nd on Saturday
Lam, please don’t change...Defence
Lam, please change...Attack

Davies is only 21

[Barney841]

Most Improved Player: naverrette
Best Newbie: partington
Surprise of the year: Sam leaving
Low point of the year: Joel’s antics
Best moment (regular season): hammering Leeds (sweet)
Worst game: wolves cc semi
Best Young Player: Tom Davies
Try of the season: Gildart against saints in 8s(when he d**ked barba)
Lam, please don’t change... defence and attitude(what wane brought what i liked)
Lam, please change... scrum half and attack plan(can get a lot more from that team)

Or something along those lines!
[/quote]

[medlocke]

Hope Lam changes the Favouritism of the boys club and plays/drops players on form

[TrueBlueWarrior]

Hope Lam changes the Favouritism of the boys club and plays/drops players on form

...and then we might win things.....oh wait!!

[thegimble]

Hope Lam changes the Favouritism of the boys club and plays/drops players on form

...and then we might win things.....oh wait!!

Wane does drop his favourites. Joel got shot asap when we could bring in Greenwood under the cap. Favouritism excuse is so wrong.

Did Wane do the right thing in dropping TT for Romain or was it favouritism. Might not like the way we play at times. But Wane put the team first every time.

[DaveO]

Hope Lam changes the Favouritism of the boys club and plays/drops players on form

...and then we might win things.....oh wait!!

Wane does drop his favourites. Joel got shot asap when we could bring in Greenwood under the cap. Favouritism excuse is so wrong.

Did Wane do the right thing in dropping TT for Romain or was it favouritism. Might not like the way we play at times. But Wane put the team first every time.

It was IL who sacked Joel, not Wane. We all know by now who stays, goes and is recruited is decided by IL and Rads. It will be IL and Rads who decide Hardakers future, not Lam.

I wonder what Wane would have done had Marshall and Isa been fit? I have always thought Wane picked the best team when he has had 17 fit players and no more! Have a choice and he might have convinced himself either of those two deserved a place due to earlier seasons efforts or whatever and I don't think we'd have won had they played because much as I love Marshall's finishing Dom is the better defender and Isa is not as good as any of the back rows who played.

Lets not forget it took an entire season for Wane to realise Powell isn't a 7 having given him the shirt based on nothing and he came up with the "switcheroo" so he could alternate the hooking and get Escare on the pitch. Was the fact Powell was given the 7 shirt based on favouritism? First name on the team sheet I believe. I have no idea but it was a mistake and it's selections like that I am looking forward to having seen the last of.

[Exiled Wiganer]

I can’t think of an instance in which Wane has selected players which are clearly not as good as those left out through favouritism. I think he may have been too soft on some players, but I would be astonished if, after the club and the player himself moved heaven and earth to come back from injury, he would not have picked Manfredi. Similarly, I don’t recall Isa being picked ahead of Farrell and Bateman (and I am pretty sure I would), and Greenwood was brought in early and picked as soon as he was fit enough.

[ancientnloyal]

...and then we might win things.....oh wait!!

Wane does drop his favourites. Joel got shot asap when we could bring in Greenwood under the cap. Favouritism excuse is so wrong.

Did Wane do the right thing in dropping TT for Romain or was it favouritism. Might not like the way we play at times. But Wane put the team first every time.

It was IL who sacked Joel, not Wane. We all know by now who stays, goes and is recruited is decided by IL and Rads. It will be IL and Rads who decide Hardakers future, not Lam.

I wonder what Wane would have done had Marshall and Isa been fit? I have always thought Wane picked the best team when he has had 17 fit players and no more! Have a choice and he might have convinced himself either of those two deserved a place due to earlier seasons efforts or whatever and I don't think we'd have won had they played because much as I love Marshall's finishing Dom is the better defender and Isa is not as good as any of the back rows who played.

Lets not forget it took an entire season for Wane to realise Powell isn't a 7 having given him the shirt based on nothing and he came up with the "switcheroo" so he could alternate the hooking and get Escare on the pitch. Was the fact Powell was given the 7 shirt based on favouritism? First name on the team sheet I believe. I have no idea but it was a mistake and it's selections like that I am looking forward to having seen the last of.

And I got slated for the #7 talk with Powell.

Well said Dave it did take 80% of the season to figure this out and I feel having Escaré at 1 and Tomkins at 6/7 with Lulu/Powell interchanging would have been much better for us.

The Sam/Morgan trick worked ok at salford then became flat and coaches knew what was coming. Powell IMO if played at 9 could be knocking on the door of England if not now certainly next season