WHICH 3 WOULD YOU DROP FOR MONDAY

[cpwigan]

My team

Ashton
Dallas
Gleeson
Goulding
Richards
Orr
Moran
Seu Seu
Godwin
Hargreaves
Tomkins
Tickle
O'Loughlin

Subs:

Palea'aesina
Higham
Brown
O'Carroll

Highly unlikely but it is my choice

[waterside glens]

looks ok to me ,i ,d swaphigham for orr just and maybe start with feka

[First Try Tickle]

cpwigan posted:
My team

Ashton
Dallas
Gleeson
Goulding
Richards
Orr
Moran
Seu Seu
Godwin
Hargreaves
Tomkins
Tickle
O'Loughlin

Subs:

Palea'aesina
Higham
Brown
O'Carroll

Highly unlikely but it is my choice

you mustn't have gone yesterday then.

Orr and Moran....at halfbacks

Weve only just managed to split them up and now you want them back together.

[cpwigan]

Sorry but I have to disagree. They are our best half back option, the halfbacks that we were reasonably successful with towards the end of last season. Who do you suggest otherwise? Higham? He does a job as an enthusiastic tackler/extra forward which was great v Saints when we knew we would lose but v London we need to win, we need to score tries. Stand-off, I still think Orr is better than Brown.

[GeoffN]

cpwigan posted:
Sorry but I have to disagree. They are our best half back option, the halfbacks that we were reasonably successful with towards the end of last season. Who do you suggest otherwise? Higham? He does a job as an enthusiastic tackler/extra forward which was great v Saints when we knew we would lose but v London we need to win, we need to score tries. Stand-off, I still think Orr is better than Brown.

I can't remember very many games, out of the 50-odd he's played for us, where Orr has shown anything near the creative ability he had at Cas. Short-term, Higham, but long-term I still think Brown deserves the chance to show what he can do (or not) at #6.

[Deb Ward]

moran wilkes jonkers

[pedro]

Moron, Konkers...and the dire guy from the NFP! JJ one by the way.

[cpwigan]

Geoff I would probably go with your view of Brown being given a chance but having seen Brown and Orr at stand off for the 21s I believe Orr to be the better option. He linked up far better with Goulding than Brown did. I see Orr more likely to put a pass on for his outside backs whereas Brown is more likely to hit a pass and whilst we have running scrum halves that will not work.

[StevosShrink]

My Team would be:

Ashton
Dallas
Goulding
Richards
Gleeson
Moran
Higham
Hargreaves
Godwin
Seu Seu
Tickle
James
O'Loughlin

Subs:

Orr
Paleaaesina
Jonkers
Tomkins

Sadly, however, I can see Brown being played in the centre and Goulding on the wing. With Gleeson dropped.

[turf]

My friend said one of the three to be dropped should be Dallas because he knocked on, on Good Friday, and then he gave a stupid penalty away for lifting the legs.

I am not so sure, I think he's just proving that he's human, because lets face it, he doesn't give many penalties away, or make many mistakes.