Page 2 of 5

Re: running for man of ste...

Posted: Wed Jul 19, 2006 6:49 pm
by pedro
Theres a good argument for Hock. Come back after a horrific injury and has changed the pack. Far better now with him and Fletcher.......Fielden too.

Re: running for man of ste...

Posted: Wed Jul 19, 2006 7:29 pm
by luke_robinsons_angel
Kevin Brown.

Seriously I think Malc Alker or Stu Feilden

Re: running for man of ste...

Posted: Wed Jul 19, 2006 7:41 pm
by GeoffN
Phil Clarke is arguing the case for Terry Matterson, the Cas coach.


http://www.skysports.com/skysports/arti ... 75,00.html

Re: running for man of ste...

Posted: Wed Jul 19, 2006 8:46 pm
by standishcat
Kevin Brown.
Good one! :lol:

My choice would be Maguire. Or Lyon.

Re: running for man of ste...

Posted: Wed Jul 19, 2006 8:54 pm
by - psycho -
i dont think lyon, he wwasnt as good as last year but has still been solid. im going to say fielden, yeaman or whellens.

Re: running for man of steel

Posted: Wed Jul 19, 2006 8:57 pm
by jimofwigan
FEILDEN FOR KEEPERS posted:
just curious who would be your favourite for man of steel this year as i think so far its got to be wellens and horne look forward to your views
My man of steel is Pat Richatds . He 's been STEELing money since he signed on for us.

The big Aussy Kitten. (he is far to gentle with the opposition to be called a pussy cat)STEELS the high ball then drops it if hit hard.

Re: running for man of ste...

Posted: Wed Jul 19, 2006 8:59 pm
by - psycho -
jimofwigan posted:
FEILDEN FOR KEEPERS posted:
just curious who would be your favourite for man of steel this year as i think so far its got to be wellens and horne look forward to your views
My man of steel is Pat Richatds . He 's been STEELing money since he signed on for us.

The big Aussy Kitten. (he is far to gentle with the opposition to be called a pussy cat)STEELS the high ball then drops it if hit hard.
harsh, hows about GIVE THE GUY A CHANCE!!!! :angry:
he's been here for a season, he hasnt had a good centre yet you are quick to criticise even when he has a high scoring try record already for this season out of our team.

Re: running for man of ste...

Posted: Wed Jul 19, 2006 9:10 pm
by jimofwigan
- psycho - posted:
jimofwigan posted:
FEILDEN FOR KEEPERS posted:
just curious who would be your favourite for man of steel this year as i think so far its got to be wellens and horne look forward to your views
My man of steel is Pat Richatds . He 's been STEELing money since he signed on for us.

The big Aussy Kitten. (he is far to gentle with the opposition to be called a pussy cat)STEELS the high ball then drops it if hit hard.
harsh, hows about GIVE THE GUY A CHANCE!!!! :angry:
he's been here for a season, he hasnt had a good centre yet you are quick to criticise even when he has a high scoring try record already for this season out of our team.
HE IS OUR CENTRE

Re: running for man of ste...

Posted: Wed Jul 19, 2006 9:13 pm
by - psycho -
jimofwigan posted:
- psycho - posted:
jimofwigan posted: My man of steel is Pat Richatds . He 's been STEELing money since he signed on for us.

The big Aussy Kitten. (he is far to gentle with the opposition to be called a pussy cat)STEELS the high ball then drops it if hit hard.
harsh, hows about GIVE THE GUY A CHANCE!!!! :angry:
he's been here for a season, he hasnt had a good centre yet you are quick to criticise even when he has a high scoring try record already for this season out of our team.
HE IS OUR CENTRE
HE ISNT A CENTRE. when will you get that into your head. where did he play for wests? wing. where did he play best for us? wing. suprise suprise. you are very quick to judge someone from one season when i have no doubts you have slagged the likes of orr off in the past. look what is happening to him of late now he has a good half back partener. give richards a good centre and watch him shine.

Re: running for man of ste...

Posted: Wed Jul 19, 2006 9:19 pm
by jimofwigan
- psycho - posted:
jimofwigan posted:
- psycho - posted: harsh, hows about GIVE THE GUY A CHANCE!!!! :angry:
he's been here for a season, he hasnt had a good centre yet you are quick to criticise even when he has a high scoring try record already for this season out of our team.
HE IS OUR CENTRE
HE ISNT A CENTRE. when will you get that into your head. where did he play for wests? wing. where did he play best for us? wing. suprise suprise. you are very quick to judge someone from one season when i have no doubts you have slagged the likes of orr off in the past. look what is happening to him of late now he has a good half back partener. give richards a good centre and watch him shine.
I hear what you say . But he was bought as a centre. Dallas and Calderwood are our first choice wingers. If Nobby says he is good enough to get in the side I will go along with that. I will also say that the wing may be his best position but there will not be a vacancy there untill next season. Right now in the dog fight at the bottom he has not got the guts and the bottle to be there mixing it with this side