cpwigan wrote:DaveO wrote:cpwigan wrote:Matthew keeps tryping defeatist. Well so far if we accept your views we were somehow robbed v Cats but given Hudds got robbed v us I think the adage is correct. Try replacing defeatist for realist.
How were Hudds robbed? Did the ref give us the means to win the game? I don't recall their coach having a go at the ref whereas ours was not happy with the refs decisions at the end.
Dave you are either
1) A liar
2) Totally biased
3) Ignorant
The above comments are bang out of order.
For a teacher you have a poor grasp of grammar. I said
"
I don't recall their coach having a go...."
I guess that makes me a liar does it?
Had I said "Sharp did not have a go" you might have had a point. I suggest you think before you hit the keyboard next time.
Even then you would be playing semantics because I was referring to Sharp complaining about the tries we scored to win the game and given the context of this discussion I thought that was obvious.
I suggest you Admit you were wrong and apologise. Are you man enough to do that?
I have just proven you wrong and everybody else has the evidence.
Their coach was clearly unhappy about the officiating throughout the match. Fair enough. Nobby has been unhappy about the officiating in some of our games as well.
However the point I was making was that those two tries we scored to win that game were NOT the result of a controversial decision by the referee.
Hence my question above "How were Hudds robbed?" and "Did the ref give us the means to win the game?" meaning he didn't give us an incorrect decision enabling us to win it at the death - as Klien did with Les Cats on Friday.
The winning try for Les Cats did follow what WAS a controversial decision.
Am I wrong? Yes or no?
Did sharp complain about the build up to either Wigan try? I don't think he did. Am I wrong?
Did Sharp complain about either try specifically for infringements in the build up to either that were missed by the ref?
I don't think he did.
But I will let you set me right on all the above as I do not recall specific complaints about the build up to either try but if there were complaints, I am sure you will know.
I await my apology Dave and you can remove the egg from your face
I think your are the one with egg on your face due to your choice of language.
Now you know exactly what I was on about - did the ref in the Hudds game make a similar error in the build up to either of the late Wigan tries to let us win the match?
Mind you if he did you will have to explain the relevance to what happened on Friday because as far as I can see there can't be any except perhaps two games were decided by the refs actions not one.
Dave