The Charnley Try ?

[Aaron C. Rescue]

Apparently photos now on James Child twitter account show he got the decision correct.

[markill]

http://www.therfl.co.uk/asktheref_6th_august

James Child - Wigan Warriors v Hull KR
RT @jackhouseman how was josh chanleys 2nd try against hull kr given? #AskTheRef



.@jackhouseman Having viewed 3 different angles of the ball & touch in goal line, in my opinion 2 angles (see next tweets) showed the..

.@jackhouseman ball was grounded first on the goal line before touching the in goal line so the balance of evidence was a try. JC

Follow this link to see the pictures.

[yokozuna]

[IMG]http://i24.photobucket.com/albums/c17/J ... 1sttry.png[/IMG]

The ball does appear to be on the try-line before it touches the side-line.

[LORENZO]

So the video ref was correct all along.Not a strong supporter of ref Childs but well done to him this time.
Now can we see the last KR try where I believe he lost the ball.
And please send them both to those two idiots at Sky who thought KR were robbed.

[josie andrews]

So the video ref was correct all along.Not a strong supporter of ref Childs but well done to him this time.
Now can we see the last KR try where I believe he lost the ball.
And please send them both to those two idiots at Sky who thought KR were robbed.

And Bill Arthur, Shaun McCrae, Terry O'Connor & even Stuart Cummings!!!

According to Super League Full Time