Page 3 of 3
Re: Honest Assessment!
Posted: Sun Aug 18, 2013 2:54 pm
by NeeNawWarrior22
donny wrote:after 60yrs of wigan rl I have had enough after these last few weeks we have gone from world beaters into the laughing stock of super league,I am very disapointed in Shaun Wane, and i would get rid,I would drop Sam Tompkins for wembley,he obviously dousn't want to play for us,we must have the worst centres in super league in Gelling and Thornley ,the half backs are non existant,and Richards is the new slug,Logan tompkins is very average,I could go on but but it wont help matters,I sit here and dream of the old days, when we didnt have a subs bench,and all the players had full time jobs,and all the players played up to and before the cup final,there was no resting of players,I think Wigan will be hard pushed to finish half way nest season,they need a clear out.I will sign out for the last and wish the supporters of this once great club the best of success in the future, ive had enough i cant take anymore Good bye.
What makes you think Tomkins doesn't want to play for us? Your idea of dropping him is absolutely ludicrous. Who do you propose replacing him with, Hampshire? Tierney? They are not ready yet. We are talking about the best player in Super League here, dropping him isn't worth considering. I don't believe the half backs are inconsistent, I think at this present time they are not very effective due to Greens poor form. I'm a massive fan of Smith, but he's not been as effective due to his partners form. But hey, poor form exists in sport and it happens. Your comment appears very knee jerk and I'm sorry to say, a bit offside.
Re: Honest Assessment!
Posted: Sun Aug 18, 2013 4:31 pm
by phild1
Shaun1967 wrote:Wes wrote:
12 Farrell, runs good lines an plays above his weight, offers himself up on Greens flat pass too much as its easily read.
His role is to offer himself as an option to Green EVERY TIME. The problem is we aren't offering other options so that's why it's easily read.
==phild1 Farrell should be running on to balls when a gap has been opened up for him not try to take on two or three would be tacklers.props to make the hard yards back rowers to run on to balls.
Re: Honest Assessment!
Posted: Sun Aug 18, 2013 8:37 pm
by KaylaRobbo
'Donny' sorry but I think you got the wrong web-site. Think you were looking for the Samaritans.
Cheer up - we've been through all this before - as have all teams.
Let's not forget that we have a week now to try and get positive. At this rate we'll all be tripping up on our bottom lips as we walk up to Wembley!
C'mon guys(and gals)- if the worst comes to the worst then we can do all this next week but until then lets not forget the 'loyal' in 'ancient and loyal'.
There's still all to play for yet...
Re: Honest Assessment!
Posted: Sun Aug 18, 2013 11:12 pm
by cpwigan
1 Sam, FANTASTIC ATTACKER, Best in SL. Needs to run more himself after fielding long kicks. Not the best in fielding high kicks.
2 Charnley, EXCELLENT WINGER, brilliant running straight at opponents but double stepping them. Needs to hold position and trust his centre more in defence. Future place kicker?
3 Daz, EXCELLENT ALL ROUND CENTRE; Needs to try top find an extra 1/2 yard of speed over first 5/10/15 yards
4 Thornley, POTENTIALLY a modern day Neil Fox but currently not developing his game as he should. Needs to improve short distance speed and evasion techniques
4 Gelling, TOO HIGH RISK
5 Pat, injuries have taken their toll. Glad he is leaving than carrying on and hurting his fantastic reputation.
6 Green, A RIGHTY playing LEFTY!!
7 Smith, Decent 7, needs to work on his evasion skills / speed?.
8 Eric, LEE HANSEN WAS BETTER, GARBAGE.
9 Mickey Mac, EXCELLENT, needs to play the full 80!
10 Moose, Superb, wrongly criticised by some of our fans. Wane Game Plan stops him playing as he can / should. Still our best prop!
11 Hansen, Excellent defender, wrist injury hurts his running ability.
12 Farrell, Very good, great ENGINE.
13 Lockers, BEST PLAYER IN SL