Page 3 of 10

Re: Wane without a whole team!!

Posted: Wed May 03, 2017 8:58 am
by markill
Widnes have used more players than us this season. Huddersfield possibly have too.

Re: Wane without a whole team!!

Posted: Wed May 03, 2017 11:36 am
by The booze hound
Caboosegg wrote:
jaws1 wrote:Easter games ok why is just Wigan that kops all the injuries?
form for every team dips after easter
Impossible.

Re: Wane without a whole team!!

Posted: Wed May 03, 2017 2:29 pm
by Exiled Wiganer
Having seen the squad, I would play Woods at 6. We need at least one half back in the half back role. If we play Gregson alongside him, who has played in the halves before for us, then we could put out this team:
Tierney - Marshall - Burgess - Forsyth - Davies - Gregson - Woods

FPN - Powell - Tautai - Sutton - Farrell - Isa

Navarette - Bretherton - Tomkins - Ganson

Sutton being fit really helps us. We won't be able to beat a good Salford side on Friday, but ought to be able to keep it more respectable than against Cas.

Add McIllorum and Lockers for Swinton, and that should be enough. Then hope and pray for some of Escare, Sam Tomkins and Williams to be fit for Wire and Saints and we could be competitive in those games.

Re: Wane without a whole team!!

Posted: Wed May 03, 2017 3:57 pm
by Nezza Faz
Exiled Wiganer wrote:Having seen the squad, I would play Woods at 6. We need at least one half back in the half back role. If we play Gregson alongside him, who has played in the halves before for us, then we could put out this team:
Tierney - Marshall - Burgess - Forsyth - Davies - Gregson - Woods

FPN - Powell - Tautai - Sutton - Farrell - Isa

Navarette - Bretherton - Tomkins - Ganson

Sutton being fit really helps us. We won't be able to beat a good Salford side on Friday, but ought to be able to keep it more respectable than against Cas.

Add McIllorum and Lockers for Swinton, and that should be enough. Then hope and pray for some of Escare, Sam Tomkins and Williams to be fit for Wire and Saints and we could be competitive in those games.

Not a bad call given the circumstances, but I'd start with Powell in the halves and Ganson at 9. Difficult to have two inexperienced halves in Gregson and Woods to start because they'd be targeted to begin with. At least in Ganson he's a recognised hooker and Powell can revert there later on to spell Ganson, and then bring in Woods/Gregson when the opening exchanges have passed to calmer waters (hopefully).

Again, not expecting a win but should be interesting and hoping the young kids can put in a performance.

Re: Wane without a whole team!!

Posted: Wed May 03, 2017 8:04 pm
by shaunedwardsfanclub
markill wrote:Widnes have used more players than us this season. Huddersfield possibly have too.
True but Huddersfield rested a few for the Swinton game and came unstuck.

Re: Wane without a whole team!!

Posted: Wed May 03, 2017 8:06 pm
by shaunedwardsfanclub
Nezza Faz wrote:
Exiled Wiganer wrote:Having seen the squad, I would play Woods at 6. We need at least one half back in the half back role. If we play Gregson alongside him, who has played in the halves before for us, then we could put out this team:
Tierney - Marshall - Burgess - Forsyth - Davies - Gregson - Woods

FPN - Powell - Tautai - Sutton - Farrell - Isa

Navarette - Bretherton - Tomkins - Ganson

Sutton being fit really helps us. We won't be able to beat a good Salford side on Friday, but ought to be able to keep it more respectable than against Cas.

Add McIllorum and Lockers for Swinton, and that should be enough. Then hope and pray for some of Escare, Sam Tomkins and Williams to be fit for Wire and Saints and we could be competitive in those games.

Not a bad call given the circumstances, but I'd start with Powell in the halves and Ganson at 9. Difficult to have two inexperienced halves in Gregson and Woods to start because they'd be targeted to begin with. At least in Ganson he's a recognised hooker and Powell can revert there later on to spell Ganson, and then bring in Woods/Gregson when the opening exchanges have passed to calmer waters (hopefully).

Again, not expecting a win but should be interesting and hoping the young kids can put in a performance.
I'm with you Nezza. If the service is poor from the dummy half then the attach will falter so Powell and Ganson have to share the hooking duties. By the way, Salford are also busted so this game is in the balance.

Re: Wane without a whole team!!

Posted: Wed May 03, 2017 8:07 pm
by shaunedwardsfanclub
Nezza Faz wrote:
Exiled Wiganer wrote:Having seen the squad, I would play Woods at 6. We need at least one half back in the half back role. If we play Gregson alongside him, who has played in the halves before for us, then we could put out this team:
Tierney - Marshall - Burgess - Forsyth - Davies - Gregson - Woods

FPN - Powell - Tautai - Sutton - Farrell - Isa

Navarette - Bretherton - Tomkins - Ganson

Sutton being fit really helps us. We won't be able to beat a good Salford side on Friday, but ought to be able to keep it more respectable than against Cas.

Add McIllorum and Lockers for Swinton, and that should be enough. Then hope and pray for some of Escare, Sam Tomkins and Williams to be fit for Wire and Saints and we could be competitive in those games.

Not a bad call given the circumstances, but I'd start with Powell in the halves and Ganson at 9. Difficult to have two inexperienced halves in Gregson and Woods to start because they'd be targeted to begin with. At least in Ganson he's a recognised hooker and Powell can revert there later on to spell Ganson, and then bring in Woods/Gregson when the opening exchanges have passed to calmer waters (hopefully).

Again, not expecting a win but should be interesting and hoping the young kids can put in a performance.
Who would you leave out if Morgan was fit to play?

Re: Wane without a whole team!!

Posted: Wed May 03, 2017 9:08 pm
by markill
shaunedwardsfan​club​ wrote:
markill wrote:Widnes have used more players than us this season. Huddersfield possibly have too.
True but Huddersfield rested a few for the Swinton game and came unstuck.
I was on about Super League only

Re: Wane without a whole team!!

Posted: Wed May 03, 2017 11:11 pm
by Nezza Faz
shaunedwardsfan​club​ wrote:
Nezza Faz wrote:
Exiled Wiganer wrote:Having seen the squad, I would play Woods at 6. We need at least one half back in the half back role. If we play Gregson alongside him, who has played in the halves before for us, then we could put out this team:
Tierney - Marshall - Burgess - Forsyth - Davies - Gregson - Woods

FPN - Powell - Tautai - Sutton - Farrell - Isa

Navarette - Bretherton - Tomkins - Ganson

Sutton being fit really helps us. We won't be able to beat a good Salford side on Friday, but ought to be able to keep it more respectable than against Cas.

Add McIllorum and Lockers for Swinton, and that should be enough. Then hope and pray for some of Escare, Sam Tomkins and Williams to be fit for Wire and Saints and we could be competitive in those games.

Not a bad call given the circumstances, but I'd start with Powell in the halves and Ganson at 9. Difficult to have two inexperienced halves in Gregson and Woods to start because they'd be targeted to begin with. At least in Ganson he's a recognised hooker and Powell can revert there later on to spell Ganson, and then bring in Woods/Gregson when the opening exchanges have passed to calmer waters (hopefully).

Again, not expecting a win but should be interesting and hoping the young kids can put in a performance.
Who would you leave out if Morgan was fit to play?

SEFC, if Morgan Escare had just made the squad, then that's a difficult call as to who to omit. But in an effort to keep a sound mix of backs and forwards as strong as possible then I'd go with the following.

If it was down to me then probably sacrifice Navarette on the basis that if Morgan broke down with his knee injury then we'd still have something of a half back partnership with Powell and/or Woods/Gregson with Powell spelling Ganson at 9. This still leaves Joel and Bretherton available to play front row, in Navarette's absence.

What do you think ?

Re: Wane without a whole team!!

Posted: Wed May 03, 2017 11:26 pm
by shaunedwardsfanclub
Nezza Faz wrote:
shaunedwardsfan​club​ wrote:
Nezza Faz wrote:
Not a bad call given the circumstances, but I'd start with Powell in the halves and Ganson at 9. Difficult to have two inexperienced halves in Gregson and Woods to start because they'd be targeted to begin with. At least in Ganson he's a recognised hooker and Powell can revert there later on to spell Ganson, and then bring in Woods/Gregson when the opening exchanges have passed to calmer waters (hopefully).

Again, not expecting a win but should be interesting and hoping the young kids can put in a performance.
Who would you leave out if Morgan was fit to play?

SEFC, if Morgan Escare had just made the squad, then that's a difficult call as to who to omit. But in an effort to keep a sound mix of backs and forwards as strong as possible then I'd go with the following.

If it was down to me then probably sacrifice Navarette on the basis that if Morgan broke down with his knee injury then we'd still have something of a half back partnership with Powell and/or Woods/Gregson with Powell spelling Ganson at 9. This still leaves Joel and Bretherton available to play front row, in Navarette's absence.

What do you think ?
I would hope that he wouldn't play unless he was 100% ish, we don't want anymore long term injuries. I think that I would like to see him start at full back given that he has been excellent in that position and I am not one for putting round pegs in square holes. Having said that it might come to needs must. So Lewis would miss out for me with either Brethy or Nav.