George Williams May not play

[TrueBlueWarrior]

Half the team were not match fit, flowers etc etc , they were bunched and not got the energy to drive the ball in. Worst effort from Wigan I have seen in a long time, best team won.

Were Taylor and Goulding dropped or where they injured? If the former our coach is big reason why we lost today risking players not match fit. He may have thought they deserved dropping for whatever reason but if he did drop them he needs to put his hand up and except be was an idiot.

As to Williams if he went in an injury that is another mistake from Wane with Hamshire on the bench for most of the match.

You always talk/discuss/argue with many 'ifs' DaveO which straight away makes your argument/point a waste of time.

[ddtftf]

At 3pm yesterday George Williams had a cast on his hand for a scaphoid tunnel injury to his hand, he wanted to take it off to play but Peter his farther advised him not to, and left the decision to George. He has obviously decided to remove it to play, but you may now understand why I did not want to let the opposition know too soon before the game.

why post summat then!

Because it is an information board, that's why I posted summat

[Wiganer Ted]

If Waney has been playing squad politics before selecting the best and fittest players available to play then IL needs to have words with him and very quickly.

[butt monkey]

Half the team were not match fit, flowers etc etc , they were bunched and not got the energy to drive the ball in. Worst effort from Wigan I have seen in a long time, best team won.

Were Taylor and Goulding dropped or where they injured? If the former our coach is big reason why we lost today risking players not match fit. He may have thought they deserved dropping for whatever reason but if he did drop them he needs to put his hand up and except be was an idiot.

As to Williams if he went in an injury that is another mistake from Wane with Hamshire on the bench for most of the match.

Whilst hindsight is a wonderful thing, I can't help wondering WHY Charnley was not risked but is expected to play for Workington. Yet at the same time, Flower and Farrell walked straight back into that side. Some strange selections and many questions that will never truly be answered without Wane making his selection policy for that game public

[DaveO]

Half the team were not match fit, flowers etc etc , they were bunched and not got the energy to drive the ball in. Worst effort from Wigan I have seen in a long time, best team won.

Were Taylor and Goulding dropped or where they injured? If the former our coach is big reason why we lost today risking players not match fit. He may have thought they deserved dropping for whatever reason but if he did drop them he needs to put his hand up and except be was an idiot.

As to Williams if he went in an injury that is another mistake from Wane with Hamshire on the bench for most of the match.

You always talk/discuss/argue with many 'ifs' DaveO which straight away makes your argument/point a waste of time.

Bullshit.

If I didn't qualify the above quoted post and had assumed they were fit you would be on me like a ton of bricks for posting speculation as facts.

In fact you already questioned me and someone else along those lines.

So what do you prefer? Me doing my best to give Wane the benefit of the doubt by saying "If injured..." or just assuming they were fit?

[ddtftf]

why post summat then!

Because it is an information board, that's why I posted summat

pre game you didn't post any information


You have lost me

[TrueBlueWarrior]

Were Taylor and Goulding dropped or where they injured? If the former our coach is big reason why we lost today risking players not match fit. He may have thought they deserved dropping for whatever reason but if he did drop them he needs to put his hand up and except be was an idiot.

As to Williams if he went in an injury that is another mistake from Wane with Hamshire on the bench for most of the match.

You always talk/discuss/argue with many 'ifs' DaveO which straight away makes your argument/point a waste of time.

Bullshit.

If I didn't qualify the above quoted post and had assumed they were fit you would be on me like a ton of bricks for posting speculation as facts.

In fact you already questioned me and someone else along those lines.

So what do you prefer? Me doing my best to give Wane the benefit of the doubt by saying "If injured..." or just assuming they were fit?

Have you never heard of the phrase 'reserve judgment'? You have got 3 very big ifs in your post that I responded to, now the thing is I don't disagree with what you are saying and yes you could be right but we will probably never know so it's a waste of time posting it. However you are entitled to post whatever you like, maybe the truth will come out and prove you right, which it wouldn't surprise me! I just prefer to discuss facts.

Ps. Be careful I got banned for 2 weeks saying someone was talking BS.