Page 4 of 4

Re: FPN....AGAIN!

Posted: Tue Aug 01, 2017 2:07 am
by markill
shaunedwardsfan​club​ wrote:
markill wrote:His second half spell yesterday was as good a spell as he has had all year. Yes he made a bad error to start the game and he probably stayed on a set too long in the first half, but credit where it's due for his second half.
Was it his error or MM's pass?
Error probably wasn't the right word, as I was thinking more about his run that got things started so badly. Credit to him bouncing back and having a top have, especially in his 2nd spell where he was excellent.

Re: FPN....AGAIN!

Posted: Sat Aug 05, 2017 12:16 am
by dave_highfive1
Josie's friend wrote:
shaunedwardsfan​club​ wrote:Somebody has changed his style of play from his NRL days :conf:
IMO this is the answer to his form this season, Wane likes small props who don't perform like a quality prop should. He prefers to them sticking to defence and offering nothing in attack.
FPN, Clubb, Sutton & Tautai would shine under a different coach or at least different tactics
Plus 10

Re: FPN....AGAIN!

Posted: Sat Aug 05, 2017 1:20 am
by DaveO
dave_highfive1 wrote:
Josie's friend wrote:
shaunedwardsfan​club​ wrote:Somebody has changed his style of play from his NRL days :conf:
IMO this is the answer to his form this season, Wane likes small props who don't perform like a quality prop should. He prefers to them sticking to defence and offering nothing in attack.
FPN, Clubb, Sutton & Tautai would shine under a different coach or at least different tactics
Plus 10
I have thought for several seasons we sign players who look good for other teams then when they get here play them completely differently.

I can't remember his name off hand but this started a few years back when we signed someone off Hull (not Taylor) or possibly Wakey who had had a massive game v us in the 2nd row and we played him as a prop!

Re: FPN....AGAIN!

Posted: Sat Aug 05, 2017 1:26 am
by Warrior Gilfedder
DaveO wrote:
dave_highfive1 wrote:
Josie's friend wrote: IMO this is the answer to his form this season, Wane likes small props who don't perform like a quality prop should. He prefers to them sticking to defence and offering nothing in attack.
FPN, Clubb, Sutton & Tautai would shine under a different coach or at least different tactics
Plus 10
I have thought for several seasons we sign players who look good for other teams then when they get here play them completely differently.

I can't remember his name off hand but this started a few years back when we signed someone off Hull (not Taylor) or possibly Wakey who had had a massive game v us in the 2nd row and we played him as a prop!
Lauaki?

Re: FPN....AGAIN!

Posted: Sat Aug 05, 2017 1:27 am
by thegimble
Warrior Gilfedder wrote:
DaveO wrote:
dave_highfive1 wrote: Plus 10
I have thought for several seasons we sign players who look good for other teams then when they get here play them completely differently.

I can't remember his name off hand but this started a few years back when we signed someone off Hull (not Taylor) or possibly Wakey who had had a massive game v us in the 2nd row and we played him as a prop!
Lauaki?
Think it was him

Re: FPN....AGAIN!

Posted: Sat Aug 05, 2017 1:29 am
by DaveO
thegimble wrote:
Warrior Gilfedder wrote:
DaveO wrote: I have thought for several seasons we sign players who look good for other teams then when they get here play them completely differently.

I can't remember his name off hand but this started a few years back when we signed someone off Hull (not Taylor) or possibly Wakey who had had a massive game v us in the 2nd row and we played him as a prop!
Lauaki?
Think it was him
That is who I was thinking of.

Re: FPN....AGAIN!

Posted: Sat Aug 05, 2017 9:10 am
by ian.birchall
Luaki was terrible and an appalling signing. The Hull fans were ecstatic to see the back of him and were amazed he got snapped up by Wigan.
Can anyone remember the name of a good native New Zealand or 'South Sea Islands' forward we have signed in the last few years.
The last good foward we signed from down under was Hoffman and he was only here temporarily with Melbournes salary problems and before that it was Craig Smith.

Re: FPN....AGAIN!

Posted: Sat Aug 05, 2017 11:41 am
by Southern Softy
Ironically, it was his best match for us last night. Apart from his usual sluggish start when he seems to be peripheral, he was very good indeed. Didn't make much difference unfortunately.