Josh Charnley....

[moto748]

Well, indeed. Except that we haven't got (and may well never get) a fit Manfredi.

Still don't need JC IMO.

[Josie's friend]

Charnley of six years ago was better than he is now.
Bulked up way too much for me and lost a yard of pace in the process.
Give me a fit manfredi any day

A fit Manfredi has never finished top try scorer for us being beaten by either Josh or Joe. Him and Marshall are about the same level with Davies being better than both of them.
If Dom came back it wouldn't take long for the rose tinted glasses fans to see he's pretty weak in a lot of areas.

[wall_of_voodoo]

Whoopedy Doo

The "missed opportunity" was not poaching Goodwin from Leigh before the wire did when the lobbygobblers went down

[Barney841]

Charnley of six years ago was better than he is now.
Bulked up way too much for me and lost a yard of pace in the process.
Give me a fit manfredi any day

A fit Manfredi has never finished top try scorer for us being beaten by either Josh or Joe. Him and Marshall are about the same level with Davies being better than both of them.
If Dom came back it wouldn't take long for the rose tinted glasses fans to see he's pretty weak in a lot of areas.

He may not of been the highest try scorer but he had good defence and was good under the high ball and if I remember rightly manfredi kept josh out of the team before he got injured.

[mjdodge13]

No need to resign Charnley IMO. He was very average in the 2 seasons before his departure. He was a very good finisher in a very good team. Going off his last season at Wigan..........lost a yard of pace and didn’t run his weight. I’m happy Wigan haven’t spent a large amount of money to bring him back. We have 4 very good Wingers at the moment who are all willing to work hard for a place in the team. I think it shows how valued he is that Sale let him leave for free and Wigan passed him up!

[Josie's friend]

Charnley of six years ago was better than he is now.
Bulked up way too much for me and lost a yard of pace in the process.
Give me a fit manfredi any day

A fit Manfredi has never finished top try scorer for us being beaten by either Josh or Joe. Him and Marshall are about the same level with Davies being better than both of them.
If Dom came back it wouldn't take long for the rose tinted glasses fans to see he's pretty weak in a lot of areas.

He may not of been the highest try scorer but he had good defence and was good under the high ball and if I remember rightly manfredi kept josh out of the team before he got injured.

Josh's attitude at the time kept him out of the team. Dom's defence was crap with zero positional sense, his side was a target for opposing sides just like it is when Marshall plays.
Dom's positive is that while running forward he was hard to get hold of and had some strength. The was dependant ofc that he didn't cut in (which he mostly did) and lost all momentum.
Dom has scored some great tries for us but that doesn't changed the fact he's second rate

[Barney841]

A fit Manfredi has never finished top try scorer for us being beaten by either Josh or Joe. Him and Marshall are about the same level with Davies being better than both of them.
If Dom came back it wouldn't take long for the rose tinted glasses fans to see he's pretty weak in a lot of areas.

He may not of been the highest try scorer but he had good defence and was good under the high ball and if I remember rightly manfredi kept josh out of the team before he got injured.

Josh's attitude at the time kept him out of the team. Dom's defence was crap with zero positional sense, his side was a target for opposing sides just like it is when Marshall plays.
Dom's positive is that while running forward he was hard to get hold of and had some strength. The was dependant ofc that he didn't cut in (which he mostly did) and lost all momentum.
Dom has scored some great tries for us but that doesn't changed the fact he's second rate

Well when your 21 years old and play second fiddle to someone who’s been in the team for a few years his positional play could be questioned but as time when on and if he got a regular run in the team that would come on, Dom was better than one on one tackles than josh.
Also remember when dom got a first look in the team josh had been a first team regular for 3-4 years before dom got his injury as well, I can remember him and Bateman carried us one season(can’t quite remember which one).
If dom hadn’t of got badly injured he would be the first name on the team sheet and he would be playing for England now.

[TrueBlueWarrior]

In his last season with us Josh played arguably the best RL of his career resulting in his last GF win, I personally thought he was outstanding at the business end of that season!

[Josie's friend]

In his last season with us Josh played arguably the best RL of his career resulting in his last GF win, I personally thought he was outstanding at the business end of that season!

As someone mentioned on this thread or that other one, there was definitely some issue with Wane. It was only once he secured his move away that his form came back.
To be fair he didn't exactly help himself with his attitude and pissed off a lot of supporters.

[TrueBlueWarrior]

In his last season with us Josh played arguably the best RL of his career resulting in his last GF win, I personally thought he was outstanding at the business end of that season!

As someone mentioned on this thread or that other one, there was definitely some issue with Wane. It was only once he secured his move away that his form came back.
To be fair he didn't exactly help himself with his attitude and pissed off a lot of supporters.

I agree there was definitely a fallout with Wane at some point and his form was patchy at best in his last couple of seasons. However, the point I am making is that his form at the business end of his last season was fantastic and it would have put him head and shoulders above all our current wingers IF he could have come back and maintained it!