Re: POWELL!!
Posted: Sun Sep 11, 2022 2:34 pm
Wigan_forever1985 wrote: ↑Sun Sep 11, 2022 11:07 amI agree and it’s nice to debate someone who actually responds to the points madeExiled Wiganer wrote: ↑Sun Sep 11, 2022 9:13 am I think that Chariots’ post is excellent. I disagree with some elements of it, but it is cogent and measured.
I’m retort there are a few areas where I think myself and chariots disagree that aren’t as much debatable as they are differences in opinion
My view is 9 is one of if not the most important role in the pitch so I’d be happy to divert resources to getting a better one - for example I’d rather have a poorer second row and better hooker but either one has merits
There are a couple of points though I’d argue back in
The idea powell has talent it just needs bringing out - he’s 30 - he isn’t getting any better now the slide you talk of the others on - is the same one powell will be in yet starting from a lower point
What you do at school boy is sadly many many players never go on to be anything in the professional ranks after impressive junior records
The other point on O’Neill fighting it out with Sam for the 9 jersey - I’d be happy with that too but I get the feeling that unless Sam is injured he plays - so that’s not a fair fight
We will see soon because O’Neill has been in great form and should remain in the team but I’m putting money on him being chucked as soon as Sam can play. In addition we seem to be against a 9 rotation that involves 2 9’s usually shorrocks is put on the bench as either an emergency 9 or We move around the back line to get Cust in at 9
But I’d Powell plays he will usually barring injury play 80mins which is going to serious limit O’Neils chances
He was voted Players Player of the Year in 2016I know people dont want it to be true but he is painfully average and just doesnt contribute enough for a top team hooker. Its not just the national team he is over looked - he's no awards to his name either - you know the recongition from your peers - when was the last time he won MOM or was the stand out player? if you cant stand out playing 80 mintues touching the ball more than anyone else surely that says something