Page 10 of 18

Re: george williams to australia

Posted: Fri Aug 03, 2018 10:12 am
by thegimble
Wigan_forever19​85​ wrote:
old hooker wrote:
No straw damn us wrote:If Williams is "so poor" why the interest from Australia?
They took sarge and he is very poor.
They also took richie mathers and scott moore - they arent infallible and often they take punts, josh hodgson was a nobody when he went over likewise Mike Cooper.

Williams for me is an Albert Kelly type player, put him with a steady 7 who manages the game and he is deadly - give him the responsibility of managing the game and he is bang average

Richardson is better than Williams btw
And the fuse just got lit.

Re: george williams to australia

Posted: Fri Aug 03, 2018 12:03 pm
by fozzieskem
The first time I clapped eyes on Richardson I thought him good,he just gets better though each time I see him,quite how he wasn’t picked for the Denver test I’ll never know,he’s good enough,if and when Holbrook goes home I wonder if he will alert teams over there to him? Assuming they all ready know of course it seems to me always better coming from the horses mouth so to speak

Re: george williams to australia

Posted: Fri Aug 03, 2018 12:09 pm
by Wigan_forever1985
fozzieskem wrote:The first time I clapped eyes on Richardson I thought him good,he just gets better though each time I see him,quite how he wasn’t picked for the Denver test I’ll never know,he’s good enough,if and when Holbrook goes home I wonder if he will alert teams over there to him? Assuming they all ready know of course it seems to me always better coming from the horses mouth so to speak
He really reminds me of long and having long teaching him will help him develop no end. He's cocky - like a scrum half should be he tries things others wouldnt and wants to be the centre of every play - again like a good scrum half should be




Re: george williams to australia

Posted: Fri Aug 03, 2018 3:16 pm
by old hooker
Wigan_forever19​85​ wrote:
old hooker wrote:
No straw damn us wrote:If Williams is "so poor" why the interest from Australia?
They took sarge and he is very poor.
They also took richie mathers and scott moore - they arent infallible and often they take punts, josh hodgson was a nobody when he went over likewise Mike Cooper.

Williams for me is an Albert Kelly type player, put him with a steady 7 who manages the game and he is deadly - give him the responsibility of managing the game and he is bang average

Richardson is better than Williams btw

You are right Richardson is a better player tha Williams, and the latter is not fit to lace Kellys boots.

Re: george williams to australia

Posted: Fri Aug 03, 2018 3:17 pm
by shaunedwardsfanclub
Wigan_forever19​85​ wrote:
old hooker wrote:
No straw damn us wrote:If Williams is "so poor" why the interest from Australia?
They took sarge and he is very poor.
They also took richie mathers and scott moore - they arent infallible and often they take punts, josh hodgson was a nobody when he went over likewise Mike Cooper.

Williams for me is an Albert Kelly type player, put him with a steady 7 who manages the game and he is deadly - give him the responsibility of managing the game and he is bang average

Richardson is better than Williams btw
That's interesting, why do you think so?

Re: george williams to australia

Posted: Fri Aug 03, 2018 4:08 pm
by Wigan_forever1985
shaunedwardsfan​club​ wrote:
Wigan_forever19​85​ wrote:
old hooker wrote: They took sarge and he is very poor.
They also took richie mathers and scott moore - they arent infallible and often they take punts, josh hodgson was a nobody when he went over likewise Mike Cooper.

Williams for me is an Albert Kelly type player, put him with a steady 7 who manages the game and he is deadly - give him the responsibility of managing the game and he is bang average

Richardson is better than Williams btw
That's interesting, why do you think so?
I think he just is a better all round scrum half, he runs games for saints - now granted a different coach may elevate Williams but a documented issue for Williams is how vocal he is and how much command he takes of a game. Bennett told him this was an area of his game he had to address but even after a couple of years i don't see it improving.

Williams has got a cruel step and is good off the cuff but for me Richardson runs the game, he sets the plays up and dominates play like long used to do. Williams can go missing in games.

i just think Richardson has more in his arsenal

Re: george williams to australia

Posted: Fri Aug 03, 2018 5:10 pm
by ddtftf
No straw damn us wrote:If Williams is "so poor" why the interest from Australia?


Sorry could not resist " They gave Sargenson a contract " and he was sensational at the Gold Coast I think not . then the bastards dumped him back on us to make us pay.

Re: george williams to australia

Posted: Fri Aug 03, 2018 5:13 pm
by thegimble
ddtftf wrote:
No straw damn us wrote:If Williams is "so poor" why the interest from Australia?


Sorry could not resist " They gave Sargenson a contract " and he was sensational at the Gold Coast I think not . then the bastards dumped him back on us to make us pay.
Lol

They were looking for idiots who buys back failed players and they knew where to go to.

Re: george williams to australia

Posted: Fri Aug 03, 2018 6:53 pm
by Suzieb
I wont miss him never markee pkayer

Re: george williams to australia

Posted: Sat Aug 04, 2018 8:11 pm
by ian b
Suzieb wrote:I wont miss him never markee pkayer
i wouldn't want him to go and under a new coach who knows how good he could be