It Was Not Only Silverwood...........

[turf]

That has had a mixed game this weekend. Mr Thaler at Castleford vs Harlequins apparently had a very poor game generally.

Although having watched it again, I thought that to be fair Silverwood did ok apart from their (Bradford's) first try (where he didn't blow the whistle to restart play) and their last try where he didn't give the knock on and then even had the nerve to say/signal that it went backwards?!?! :conf: :conf:

Possibly a couple of the 50/50 decisions/penalties could have gone other ways to what they did but as they say "things even them out over the course of the season".


Apparently our good old friend Mr Steve Ganson didn't do himself any favouors either up at the Galpharm Stadium with Huddersfield vs Hull.

The standards of SL referees are definately slipping. I reckon Silverwood is the decent referee at the minute.

[butt monkey]

Mr Thaler at Castleford vs Harlequins apparently had a very poor game generally.

How do you know this? :eh: It would depend on which coach you listen too.

I thought that to be fair Silverwood did ok apart from their last try where he didn't give the knock on and then even had the nerve to say/signal that it went backwards?!?

It wasn't a knock on!! It went backwards, how could that be a "knock on"? :sly:

Apparently our good old friend Mr Steve Ganson didn't do himself any favouors either up at the Galpharm Stadium with Huddersfield vs Hull

You must get to a lot of games turf Or are you just listening to the radio commentators? But why any around the Greater Manchester region would broadcast Huddersfield v Hull beggars belief

The standards of SL referees are definately slipping. I reckon Silverwood is the decent referee at the minute.

Based on what you saw on TV? :eh: With added opinions from Stevo

[turf]

Otherwise all is ok on my post butt monkey?? :sly: :sly:

I don't base my opinions on Stevo's. I base them on my own.

Jeez, I cannot have my own opinion on the standard of refereeing in SL?!?!

[medlocke]

Otherwise all is ok on my post butt monkey?? :sly: :sly:

I don't base my opinions on Stevo's. I base them on my own.

Jeez, I cannot have my own opinion on the standard of refereeing in SL?!?!

Cause your usualy full of shite :exc: :exc: :exc: :sly: :sly: :eusa9: :eusa11: :eusa14:

[GeoffN]

Otherwise all is ok on my post butt monkey?? :sly: :sly:

I don't base my opinions on Stevo's. I base them on my own.

Jeez, I cannot have my own opinion on the standard of refereeing in SL?!?!

How can you have your own opinion on a game you didn't see?

[butt monkey]

Otherwise all is ok on my post butt monkey?? :sly: :sly:

I don't base my opinions on Stevo's. I base them on my own.

Jeez, I cannot have my own opinion on the standard of refereeing in SL?!?!

Cause your usualy full of shite :exc: :exc: :exc: :sly: :sly: :eusa9: :eusa11: :eusa14:

Succinctly put Medlocke!!! :eusa12:

[DaveO]

I didn't think Silverwood was that bad. At least he wasn't afraid to sin bin players for professional fouls.

It did seem he penalised us and then Bradford in turn but if you watch the game we cleaned things up and they started to mess about.

The big issue for me was forward passes. Some of them were ridiculous and they were not all from Bradford. However what can the refs do when they have to be on the 10m defensive line so they can keep the players on-side with respect to the new rules?

Dave

[DaveO]

Cause your usualy full of shite :exc: :exc: :exc: :sly: :sly: :eusa9: :eusa11: :eusa14:

Now play nicely! No need for the above.

Dave

[turf]

DaveO posted:

No need for the above.

Well said DaveO!!

You're a MOD DaveO, you know what to do. Lock it Before medlocke says something worse!!

[gpartin]

And Medlocke wins my nomination for post of the month!

[hr]