Referees

[mike binder]

me 2 do the refs still get points off the teams 4 there performance

[Doveoverdave]

Doveoverdave posted:
Didn't see the game.

Apparently the ref was awful again. Reading match reports this morning and the ref does get a mention
"Warriors closed the gap with a hugely controversial try.....Rae furiously confrontng the ref KK".

Not a single mention of this in all of last nights posts.


Geof replied;
Because it wasn't worth mentioning.

Seen it now Geoff and it was absolutely, without doubt NO TRY!

[MrsLam]

Doveoverdave posted:

Doveoverdave posted:
Didn't see the game.

Apparently the ref was awful again. Reading match reports this morning and the ref does get a mention
"Warriors closed the gap with a hugely controversial try.....Rae furiously confrontng the ref KK".

Not a single mention of this in all of last nights posts.


Geof replied;
Because it wasn't worth mentioning.

Seen it now Geoff and it was absolutely, without doubt NO TRY!

What try is this and why isn't it a try?

[Doveoverdave]

The 1/2 time hooter try.

[MrsLam]

I read something about this the other day, the ref said he couldnt hear the hooter. It went on long enough but there was alot of shouting at the time to get that try before half time

[Doveoverdave]

My point is agree or disagree about the try all must agree that the decision as highly contentious. Not a single mention of this in all the post match reports.

KK was abysmal, every one agrees so I will concur.
Geoff thought the incident not worth a mention, but was prepared to list the faults of KK in a way that makes him appear biased against Wigan.

Message to Geoff "The rounabouts have arrived!"

KK was poor but we still got our share of decisions.
50/50?

[GeoffN]

Doveoverdave posted:
Message to Geoff "The rounabouts have arrived!"

KK was poor but we still got our share of decisions.
50/50?

Errr....will you accept 60/40? In a 4-point game that's enough!
BTW, I'm not going to criticise Laughton in advance! Although incompetent, he's normally equally so for both sides.

[jinkin jimmy]

GeoffN posted:

Doveoverdave posted:
Message to Geoff "The rounabouts have arrived!"

KK was poor but we still got our share of decisions.
50/50?

Errr....will you accept 60/40? In a 4-point game that's enough!
BTW, I'm not going to criticise Laughton in advance! Although incompetent, he's normally equally so for both sides.

Was he the ref that just sent Pryce off? If so, I thought he had a good game. Therefore, with swings and roundabouts in mind, prepare for a stinker from him tomorrow!!

[mike binder]

at the riversiders meeting on tuesday millward said the rfl were hopeing to have six full time refs next year which he hopes will give us more consistancy we now have 1 this year and he reckons hes the most improved this year that being ashley clein ,hes also nor looking forward to ganson hes never had him before .what do you think and is this the answer to our prayers :eusa2:

[MrsLam]

Full time or part time they're only human and they're still going to get things wrong in the fans eyes. I don't think it will solve anything.