Page 1 of 5

We should sign a crowd pleaser

Posted: Mon Feb 19, 2018 12:58 am
by catman
I wish the club would sign an old fashioned crowd pleaser type of player. A player with skill, flair and determination. A player who plays with his heart on his sleeve and clearly enjoys being on the field. A player that means you look forward to the match all week and eagerly await his first touch of the ball.

In the past we've had the likes of Terry Newton, Josh Charnley Feka and Brian Carney and of course the greatest crowd pleaser of all time Henderson Gill. None of these players were world class but they were bold, determined and went for it. When they got the ball they got you out of your seat and you enjoyed the game.

In the past few seasons players like this have been very thin on the ground as have moments of entertainment, often the players look like they have the weight of the world their shoulders and they don't wish to be out there. Who this new player could be is open to debate but a crowdpleaser would liven things up both on and off the pitch.

Re: We should sign a crowd pleaser

Posted: Mon Feb 19, 2018 2:00 am
by Fujiman
catman wrote:I wish the club would sign an old fashioned crowd pleaser type of player. A player with skill, flair and determination. A player who plays with his heart on his sleeve and clearly enjoys being on the field. A player that means you look forward to the match all week and eagerly await his first touch of the ball.

In the past we've had the likes of Terry Newton, Josh Charnley Feka and Brian Carney and of course the greatest crowd pleaser of all time Henderson Gill. None of these players were world class but they were bold, determined and went for it. When they got the ball they got you out of your seat and you enjoyed the game.

In the past few seasons players like this have been very thin on the ground as have moments of entertainment, often the players look like they have the weight of the world their shoulders and they don't wish to be out there. Who this new player could be is open to debate but a crowdpleaser would liven things up both on and off the pitch.
who would you suggest?

Re: We should sign a crowd pleaser

Posted: Mon Feb 19, 2018 9:40 am
by medlocke
Kevin Naiqama?


Re: We should sign a crowd pleaser

Posted: Mon Feb 19, 2018 9:44 am
by jasonnlouise
Albert Kelly imo we should have got him from KR before he went to Hull ,he's got that bit of xfactor about him

Re: We should sign a crowd pleaser

Posted: Mon Feb 19, 2018 10:08 am
by fozzieskem
I mentioned about Kelly on a Facebook group before he joined F.C. god almighty the ridicule I got :angry: stand by it though fine,fine player

Re: We should sign a crowd pleaser

Posted: Mon Feb 19, 2018 11:09 am
by medlocke
fozzieskem wrote:I mentioned about Kelly on a Facebook group before he joined F.C. god almighty the ridicule I got :angry: stand by it though fine,fine player
I got similar on RLfans

Re: We should sign a crowd pleaser

Posted: Mon Feb 19, 2018 11:19 am
by Wigan_forever1985
fozzieskem wrote:I mentioned about Kelly on a Facebook group before he joined F.C. god almighty the ridicule I got :angry: stand by it though fine,fine player
while i agree Kelly is a good player i don't think he is what we need, we have a Kelly style player in Williams, What we are missing is a "Smart" player, someone who's an out an out organiser

Before anyone makes the Smith comment, just no, he wasn't anything like that player - he just offered nothing else which is why people attributed "organising" to him but he didn't pull us round the park like what we need.

We need a Finch or a Green, A Trent Barrett someone with genuine rugby brain who can really pull the strings. We have a lot of good X Factor players already if we could pair them with a genuine thinker, unfortunately there aren't many of them around now because anyone of real talent wont play in our league unless a ban or similar causes it.


Re: We should sign a crowd pleaser

Posted: Mon Feb 19, 2018 12:01 pm
by the pieman
i've posted similar about this previously

i think the problem is that there is a real lack of quality players available to the super league because of the NRL salary cap etc

when i look around all the teams in SL i ask myself who would i pay to watch? Which player would pull the fans in? Who puts bums on seats?

Dont get me wrong i fully respect every single player that pulls on a shirt for our entertainment as the game is physically brutal / demanding on them all. however as a fan you want to see something different / someone special

unfortunately it feels like the days of Hanley, Offiah etc are long gone, unless SL does something different

the game feels like it has become so sanitised - a forward cant shoulder charge / no biff and the flare players are coached to be structured and not play what they see in front of them




Re: We should sign a crowd pleaser

Posted: Mon Feb 19, 2018 12:25 pm
by medlocke
the pieman wrote:i've posted similar about this previously

i think the problem is that there is a real lack of quality players available to the super league because of the NRL salary cap etc

when i look around all the teams in SL i ask myself who would i pay to watch? Which player would pull the fans in? Who puts bums on seats?

Dont get me wrong i fully respect every single player that pulls on a shirt for our entertainment as the game is physically brutal / demanding on them all. however as a fan you want to see something different / someone special

unfortunately it feels like the days of Hanley, Offiah etc are long gone, unless SL does something different

the game feels like it has become so sanitised - a forward cant shoulder charge / no biff and the flare players are coached to be structured and not play what they see in front of them


The RFL and Super League has destroyed our once great game, add to that Summer Rugby, Rule changes, Salary cap, Constantly trying to copy the Aussies, The Hetheringtons, SKY changing viewing times and days, also the spreading of the TV money to Grass Roots by the Fat Controller and his merry men, many factors but at least we are starting to remedy some of these, some however are not that easy to reverse.

Re: We should sign a crowd pleaser

Posted: Mon Feb 19, 2018 12:54 pm
by Exiled Wiganer
I would like a cheeky crafty player - like Robbie Farah. His legs may have gone but he reads a game as well as anyone in town.