Page 1 of 4

Wane to Catalans ?

Posted: Wed Apr 25, 2018 10:03 am
by First Try Tickle
Heard a rumour last night that Catalans have also approached Wane to be their coach for next year.

I'm not happy about Sam leaving for Catalans, but if he was to take Wane with him, that was ease the pain a bit.

As long as we don't do a swap for their current coach :lol:

Re: Wane to Catalans ?

Posted: Wed Apr 25, 2018 10:16 am
by josie andrews
I heard this last week, with supposedly Shaun Edwards being the replacement!

I can’t see Shaun Wane leaving unless his contract isn’t renewed.

He has always stated that this is his dream job!

Re: Wane to Catalans ?

Posted: Wed Apr 25, 2018 10:39 am
by Wandering Warrior
I've also heard the same in the pub on Saturday in Bolton. The guy was a former RL scribe who told me.
I didn't want to say out because I didn't want folk getting their hopes up!????

Re: Wane to Catalans ?

Posted: Wed Apr 25, 2018 11:55 am
by TrueBlueWarrior
Considering him and Sam hate each other apparently I can't see this happening! :wink:

Re: Wane to Catalans ?

Posted: Wed Apr 25, 2018 1:04 pm
by medlocke
Hope so, he will turn them into a champion side in no times, he is that good a coach that they should have silverware within the first season of him signing, he brought us silverware in his first season as head coach

Re: Wane to Catalans ?

Posted: Wed Apr 25, 2018 2:34 pm
by Wandering Warrior
medlocke wrote:Hope so, he will turn them into a champion side in no times, he is that good a coach that they should have silverware within the first season of him signing, he brought us silverware in his first season as head coach

:lol:

Re: Wane to Catalans ?

Posted: Wed Apr 25, 2018 10:07 pm
by Wiganer Ted
Great these rumours aren't they?

I'd be very surprised if Waney left voluntarily.
It has been said that he has a rolling contract so perhaps if Catalans have offered him a fixed term deal over say 3-4 years maybe he could be tempted. An increased financial incentive might tempt him.

Guash could have been impressed with the way Escare and Navarrete have improved under Waney to make him an offer.

Great these rumours!

Re: Wane to Catalans ?

Posted: Wed Apr 25, 2018 10:23 pm
by Mike
Thinking aloud about why he might consider this (if he ever would leave). He's been successful with Wigan starting from an already successful side. If he went to Catalan and improved them into a contender, that would be a big stepping stone to coaching in the NRL. He'd be likely to get a job at a struggling side, so proving he can improve a team would be vital to getting that sort of job.

I wonder if he'd like to coach in the NRL?

Re: Wane to Catalans ?

Posted: Wed Apr 25, 2018 11:09 pm
by 4 Generations
For me,Cut him in half and hes like a stick a rock.Says WRLFC all the way through.I like SW,last year he was incredible with the injury's and pressures placed on him.Not just on the field/club either.His passion and drive at the club are outstanding.
We have been jetlaged and a forward pass the wrong side of winning everything in front of us this year so far.but who knows.A new challenge may just be the ticket.
Lets face it.He can always go to the NRL or Catalan and then come back to Wigan. Everyone has so far and he shouldn't be physically injured on his return. Dont think its his style though,i hope not.He would be hard to replace.

4G

Re: Wane to Catalans ?

Posted: Thu Apr 26, 2018 11:37 am
by DaveO
Mike wrote:Thinking aloud about why he might consider this (if he ever would leave). He's been successful with Wigan starting from an already successful side. If he went to Catalan and improved them into a contender, that would be a big stepping stone to coaching in the NRL. He'd be likely to get a job at a struggling side, so proving he can improve a team would be vital to getting that sort of job.

I wonder if he'd like to coach in the NRL?
I think some coaches are very good at improving sides but it doesn't always follow that when they have got them up to a certain level they can then take them onto actual sustained success. This happens a lot in soccer with some coaches having made very nice living taking sides from lower divisions up even as far as the Premier League but no one would ever dream they were on a par with the likes of Klopp and Guardiola.

I am not convinced Wane fits into either category of improving coach or top flight coach. If you look at his recent Wigan record his league results have gone backwards the last three seasons in a row and his success was earlier on in his tenure as head coach when he still had a core of players schooled by Madge. Things have improved this season but the trophies are not handed out in April.

As to him leaving for Les Cats or the NRL I think those are the only two possibilities but that Les Cats is the only realistic one. The way Wigan play will not have any NRL club chasing him.

Wane like West years ago and is so associated with Wigan I doubt the fans and chairman of any other UK based SL club would think his heart would be in it coaching any team but Wigan. So I have always thought Wane was destined to suffer the same fate as Graeme West. Which is once his tenure as coach here is up there is no where for him to go.

So if Les Cats have offered him a job then if I was him I'd bite their hands off. If he does then he removes that "one club man" stone from around his neck and if he does improve them then he becomes employable at other clubs later. If he stays here until he's fired then expect to see Wane doing as West did and be driving taxis around Wigan in the future.

If he wants a long career as a coach he needs to get another job and if he can do it without being forced to try and find another position by being fired it is in his interest to do so.