Page 2 of 2

Re: Owen Farrell to Wigan?

Posted: Sat May 19, 2018 7:35 am
by Mike
Yeah, thats the problem though isn't it. Academy players that have never played league at first team level in their entire careers. All their experience has been gained using a completely different skill set and game management tactics. Doesn't sound like a recipe for a sucessful return to me.

Perhaps if they wanted to play center that would work OK, but goerge ford doesn't look like a center to me. Owen might be OK.

Re: Owen Farrell to Wigan?

Posted: Sat May 19, 2018 10:57 am
by Richymac
Kyle Eastmond has been released by Wasps could be him?

Re: Owen Farrell to Wigan?

Posted: Sat May 19, 2018 11:41 am
by adiddy
Mike wrote:Yeah, thats the problem though isn't it. Academy players that have never played league at first team level in their entire careers. All their experience has been gained using a completely different skill set and game management tactics. Doesn't sound like a recipe for a sucessful return to me.

Perhaps if they wanted to play center that would work OK, but goerge ford doesn't look like a center to me. Owen might be OK.

At least they would have an idea of league plays/structure so they wouldn't be coming back as complete learners. In recent memory, Ellis at Wire, Davies at Widnes, Botica at Wigan all came from union without ever playing league and turned out well.

I'd be very happy if we nursed Farrell through half a season until he found his feet just to have a consistent goal kicker!!!


Matt

Re: Owen Farrell to Wigan?

Posted: Sun May 20, 2018 12:40 am
by fozzieskem
I’d love to have Farrell here it won’t happen of course

Re: Owen Farrell to Wigan?

Posted: Mon May 21, 2018 6:25 am
by Mike
adiddy wrote:
Mike wrote:Yeah, thats the problem though isn't it. Academy players that have never played league at first team level in their entire careers. All their experience has been gained using a completely different skill set and game management tactics. Doesn't sound like a recipe for a sucessful return to me.

Perhaps if they wanted to play center that would work OK, but goerge ford doesn't look like a center to me. Owen might be OK.

At least they would have an idea of league plays/structure so they wouldn't be coming back as complete learners. In recent memory, Ellis at Wire, Davies at Widnes, Botica at Wigan all came from union without ever playing league and turned out well.

I'd be very happy if we nursed Farrell through half a season until he found his feet just to have a consistent goal kicker!!!


Matt
Don't remember Ellis, but Davis didn't play as either half back position in league, and Bottica required a full season on the wing before we started moving him to the halves. I wouldn't want to carry an aging RU half on the wing in the modern game, even for his kicking!

Re: Owen Farrell to Wigan?

Posted: Mon May 21, 2018 9:49 am
by Fujiman
Mike wrote:
adiddy wrote:
Mike wrote:Yeah, thats the problem though isn't it. Academy players that have never played league at first team level in their entire careers. All their experience has been gained using a completely different skill set and game management tactics. Doesn't sound like a recipe for a sucessful return to me.

Perhaps if they wanted to play center that would work OK, but goerge ford doesn't look like a center to me. Owen might be OK.

At least they would have an idea of league plays/structure so they wouldn't be coming back as complete learners. In recent memory, Ellis at Wire, Davies at Widnes, Botica at Wigan all came from union without ever playing league and turned out well.

I'd be very happy if we nursed Farrell through half a season until he found his feet just to have a consistent goal kicker!!!


Matt
Don't remember Ellis, but Davis didn't play as either half back position in league, and Bottica required a full season on the wing before we started moving him to the halves. I wouldn't want to carry an aging RU half on the wing in the modern game, even for his kicking!
Kevin Ellis?

Re: Owen Farrell to Wigan?

Posted: Mon May 21, 2018 5:00 pm
by Wintergreen
Why on earth would Farrell take a million pound pay cut to play for Wigan?

Re: Owen Farrell to Wigan?

Posted: Mon May 21, 2018 5:44 pm
by thegimble
Wintergreen wrote:Why on earth would Farrell take a million pound pay cut to play for Wigan?

Not that it will ever happen. But is there a clause in the salary cap you can bring in an Union player who has never played RL at senior level and his salary will not go on the cap.


Saying that I can not imagine IL paying anyone million pounds to play rugby.

Re: Owen Farrell to Wigan?

Posted: Mon May 21, 2018 7:41 pm
by medlocke
thegimble wrote:
Wintergreen wrote:Why on earth would Farrell take a million pound pay cut to play for Wigan?

Not that it will ever happen. But is there a clause in the salary cap you can bring in an Union player who has never played RL at senior level and his salary will not go on the cap.


Saying that I can not imagine IL paying anyone million pounds to play rugby.
Maybe we could pay him from the magic money tree, you know, the same one DaveO thinks we pay Tomkins non capped wage with :wink: :lol: :lol:

Re: Owen Farrell to Wigan?

Posted: Tue May 22, 2018 1:55 pm
by markill
George Ford was on the whippets and flat caps podcast last week saying that he would like to play in RL at some point in his career.