Charriots Offiah wrote: ↑Mon Nov 16, 2020 8:46 pm
I should add that a Grade F suspension is ridiculous for what Mac did.
I'm a big fan of Mickey, but what he did by lifting Dwyer up while he was on the floor injured was plain stupid.
He knows the rules, and without doubt, under those rules, he should have walked there and then.
He can have no complaint really whatever ban he cops.
I didn’t say he shouldn’t face the disciplinary, I said a Grade F suspension was ridiculous and that is on planet earth.
What don’t you understand?
Grade F other contrary behaviour and picking up a player laid out and blood pouring out of his mouth and nose.
Yes I think that fits “other contrary behaviour”,you don’t that’s fine
Imagine the outrage of LMS did it to some of our beloved.
Any player doing something as stupid as that no matter who they play for deserves a good time on the sidelines,while it didn’t happen,he had picked him up and it’s have been his neck?
He wasn’t to know and it’s no excuse for it either grade F is the correct charge now as to how many games he should get well that’s not for me to say but there has to be a zero tolerance to it and thankfully it’s not something you see very often
He man-handled an injured player on what planet is that ridiculous?
If there had been a competent ref he should have seen red for that alone
I didn’t say he shouldn’t face the disciplinary, I said a Grade F suspension was ridiculous and that is on planet earth.
What don’t you understand?
Grade F other contrary behaviour and picking up a player laid out and blood pouring out of his mouth and nose.
Yes I think that fits “other contrary behaviour”,you don’t that’s fine
I don’t understand it because the grades available for ‘other contrary behaviour’, are A-F!!!! Now, given that you are obviously an expert on rugby league laws could you please explain, in detail, why this is a Grade F offence? Why you are at it, could you please explain and provide examples of the type of ‘other contrary behaviour’ offences that fall into each grade? I may then better understand the rules and consequently you will not have to educate me every time I disagree with a ruling!
The “disciplinary rules” change every week & depending on the club & the player/s involved.
So please, stop bickering about rules & grades no one knows how they work!
Anyone can support a team when it is winning, that takes no courage.
But to stand behind a team, to defend a team when it is down and really needs you,
that takes a lot of courage. #18thMan