Caboosegg wrote: ↑Thu Sep 29, 2022 9:26 am
Your entitled to your opinion above but in mine your talking rubbish. Bibby I will admit has had a quiet year this time but has been a very good player for us in 2021. (Playing wing not centre)
I think you’re wrong personally. He shown out because of how bad we was. His strength was carries out of his own half. His negatives is that he constantly rushes out the defence and has no pace or step. Is he better than any 5 of saints wingers
I think your choosing to put that down to Bibby, while I have seen him do it I've also seen him have to do it because he's been left dealing with a 2 on 1 and I imagine if he didn't jump out and they scored he'd be bled for that also.
These are two reasons not to trust people.
1. We don't know them.
2. We do know them.
Caboosegg wrote: ↑Thu Sep 29, 2022 9:26 am
Your entitled to your opinion above but in mine your talking rubbish. Bibby I will admit has had a quiet year this time but has been a very good player for us in 2021. (Playing wing not centre)
I think you’re wrong personally. He shown out because of how bad we was. His strength was carries out of his own half. His negatives is that he constantly rushes out the defence and has no pace or step. Is he better than any 5 of saints wingers
I think your choosing to put that down to Bibby, while I have seen him do it I've also seen him have to do it because he's been left dealing with a 2 on 1 and I imagine if he didn't jump out and they scored he'd be bled for that also.
Nonsense. He has a habit of not reading the game properly. Go watch the try at magic that wins it for saints. He’s absolutely nowhere
I think you’re wrong personally. He shown out because of how bad we was. His strength was carries out of his own half. His negatives is that he constantly rushes out the defence and has no pace or step. Is he better than any 5 of saints wingers
I think your choosing to put that down to Bibby, while I have seen him do it I've also seen him have to do it because he's been left dealing with a 2 on 1 and I imagine if he didn't jump out and they scored he'd be bled for that also.
Nonsense. He has a habit of not reading the game properly. Go watch the try at magic that wins it for saints. He’s absolutely nowhere
Thank you for 100% proving my point.
Bibby is in a 3 attackers on 1 defender when the break happens and hasn't shot out of the line. we are down to 12 men. Don't see anyone complaining about how far back Marshall was that allowed the overlap.
These are two reasons not to trust people.
1. We don't know them.
2. We do know them.
I think your choosing to put that down to Bibby, while I have seen him do it I've also seen him have to do it because he's been left dealing with a 2 on 1 and I imagine if he didn't jump out and they scored he'd be bled for that also.
Nonsense. He has a habit of not reading the game properly. Go watch the try at magic that wins it for saints. He’s absolutely nowhere
Thank you for 100% proving my point.
Bibby is in a 3 attackers on 1 defender when the break happens and hasn't shot out of the line. we are down to 12 men. Don't see anyone complaining about how far back Marshall was that allowed the overlap.
3v2, he makes it a 3v1 by flying out missing the tackle and hanging marshy out to dry, not for the first time, if he had held his line and slid it would have been defended
I think your choosing to put that down to Bibby, while I have seen him do it I've also seen him have to do it because he's been left dealing with a 2 on 1 and I imagine if he didn't jump out and they scored he'd be bled for that also.
Nonsense. He has a habit of not reading the game properly. Go watch the try at magic that wins it for saints. He’s absolutely nowhere
Thank you for 100% proving my point.
Bibby is in a 3 attackers on 1 defender when the break happens and hasn't shot out of the line. we are down to 12 men. Don't see anyone complaining about how far back Marshall was that allowed the overlap.
He has 2 people on his inside coming across and marshy on his outside. He comes in doesn’t even take sironen out and takes himself out of the game making marshy defend a 3 vs 1. How can it be marshy fault
Nonsense. He has a habit of not reading the game properly. Go watch the try at magic that wins it for saints. He’s absolutely nowhere
Thank you for 100% proving my point.
Bibby is in a 3 attackers on 1 defender when the break happens and hasn't shot out of the line. we are down to 12 men. Don't see anyone complaining about how far back Marshall was that allowed the overlap.
He has 2 people on his inside coming across and marshy on his outside. He comes in doesn’t even take sironen out and takes himself out of the game making marshy defend a 3 vs 1. How can it be marshy fault
He has 3 saints players with the overlap running at him. Marshy to far back and our full back is nowhere near where they should be obviously Marshall and Field is down to us being at 12 men but our wingers are not normally that far back. I'm not blaming Marshall but I bet if you swapped Marshall and Bibby in that play you'd still blame Bibby for being out of position
These are two reasons not to trust people.
1. We don't know them.
2. We do know them.