Alex Walmsley

[josie andrews]

Well, supposedly out for the season after being tackled by John Asiata in the Challenge Cup semi final, has somehow made a super human recovery to be named in Friday’s St Helens squad v Hull FC!!

[Firestarter]

Well, supposedly out for the season after being tackled by John Asiata in the Challenge Cup semi final, has somehow made a super human recovery to be named in Friday’s St Helens squad v Hull FC!!

Injected up as saints tend to do.No need to bother ,he wont be fit so it will work in our favour if we face them

[the pieman]

Well, supposedly out for the season after being tackled by John Asiata in the Challenge Cup semi final, has somehow made a super human recovery to be named in Friday’s St Helens squad v Hull FC!!

Injected up as saints tend to do.No need to bother ,he wont be fit so it will work in our favour if we face them

agreed, he wont be fit, and also hadnt played particularly well this season anyway

he's got at best 2 or 3 games left this season, and a big gamble i think by Saints to get some impact out of him. it may backfire and he misses all the off season and start of next season.

Much like Havard / Byrne, if we try and play one of them, then the chance is they wont be fit for the start of next season

[fozzieskem]

Always thought he's make a reappearance this season but will he be fit I doubt it

[Charriots Offiah]

Well, supposedly out for the season after being tackled by John Asiata in the Challenge Cup semi final, has somehow made a super human recovery to be named in Friday’s St Helens squad v Hull FC!!

Injected up as saints tend to do.No need to bother ,he wont be fit so it will work in our favour if we face them

agreed, he wont be fit, and also hadnt played particularly well this season anyway

he's got at best 2 or 3 games left this season, and a big gamble i think by Saints to get some impact out of him. it may backfire and he misses all the off season and start of next season.

Much like Havard / Byrne, if we try and play one of them, then the chance is they wont be fit for the start of next season

Byrne has no chance, we will have to wait and see about Havard. Isa will definitely be back.

[buttmonkey2]

Isa will definitely be back.

Not played a full game since April 23rd. He should only be "back" if we had 17 injured players

Not match fit enough to risk involvement at this point of the season.

Peet's made this mistake once before with Powell. Would speak volumes of him as a coach to repeat the mistake - especially when the risks outweigh the positives

[josie andrews]

Isa will definitely be back.

Not played a full game since April 23rd. He should only be "back" if we had 17 injured players

Not match fit enough to risk involvement at this point of the season.

Peet's made this mistake once before with Powell. Would speak volumes of him as a coach to repeat the mistake - especially when the risks outweigh the positives

Exactly this!

[Dreamteam]

Isa allows rotation for kpp to do longer stints at prop considering we’ve got 3 out for the season. Hill and junior should not be doing long minutes in cut throat matches. I’m already very worried for the Leigh and possible semi final game with hill potentially getting targeted in defence.

[Bobby-WRL]

Agree
Hopefully playoffs

Field
Marshall
Wardle
King
Miski
French
Smith
Ellis
O’Neil
KPP
Faz
Nsemba
Smithies

Mago
Dupree
Isa
Powell

Harvard a probability too but not sure who drops out then

[fozzieskem]

Isa will definitely be back.

Not played a full game since April 23rd. He should only be "back" if we had 17 injured players

Not match fit enough to risk involvement at this point of the season.

Peet's made this mistake once before with Powell. Would speak volumes of him as a coach to repeat the mistake - especially when the risks outweigh the positives

Oh my this! Let’s hope lessons learned from last season where bringing players back in to early