supurb ending

[leeh2101]

we played well 2night but gave away far to many penalties,thought withers had a good game compared to friday, fielden needs to improve alot his performances this year have been terrible. just glad we took home the 2 points

[Susi]

was very close match. Fielden needs keep his cool so does hock. thought we played better than friday. WE must stop giving silly penalties away though.
well done lads.

[turf]

Could someone explain to me the penalising of Mr Ashton for a so called in correct play the ball as the sky caption said.

I am sure he penalised him because his ball carrying arm hit the ground? If this is so, Mr Silverwood got this call absolutely spot on.

[superleague]

turf posted:
Could someone explain to me the penalising for so called in correct play the ball as the sky cation said.

I am sure he penalised him because his ball carrying arm hit the ground? If this is so, Mr Silverwood got this call absolutely spot on.

your on about ashton i presume, he never had a hand on him he was within his rights to get back up

[pedro]

superleague posted:

turf posted:
Could someone explain to me the penalising for so called in correct play the ball as the sky cation said.

I am sure he penalised him because his ball carrying arm hit the ground? If this is so, Mr Silverwood got this call absolutely spot on.

your on about ashton i presume, he never had a hand on him he was within his rights to get back up

ball carrying arm didnt hit the floor when the player had a hand on him...watch it again its quite clear.

[superleague]

pedro posted:

superleague posted:

turf posted:
Could someone explain to me the penalising for so called in correct play the ball as the sky cation said.

I am sure he penalised him because his ball carrying arm hit the ground? If this is so, Mr Silverwood got this call absolutely spot on.

your on about ashton i presume, he never had a hand on him he was within his rights to get back up

ball carrying arm didnt hit the floor when the player had a hand on him...watch it again its quite clear.

i'm not saying your wrong but it must of been for a split second

[pedro]

nope looked a bad decision on the replay. even all the commentators called it. (rare)

[waterside glens]

bad decision end off.why could the video ref not tell him he was wrong like the one did for ganson during the hull game when he made a mistake

[Stev0]

pedro posted:
nope looked a bad decision on the replay. even all the commentators called it. (rare)

Your may be right, but he called it , so we need to move on... you get these sort of decisions every game, you've really got to take them on the chin and move on.

[DaveO]

Stev0 posted:

pedro posted:
nope looked a bad decision on the replay. even all the commentators called it. (rare)

Your may be right, but he called it , so we need to move on... you get these sort of decisions every game, you've really got to take them on the chin and move on.

That depends whether you are discussing how well the ref did or not. They are full time now and I expect better from them than what we are seeing. Refs call a lot of things but if they get them wrong it isn't very good when everyone can see it's obvious. The take it on the chin idea is letting thm off too easily IMO especially if it isn't just the odd decision.

I mean lets face it we won and we still have issues with the ref which says quite a bit to me.

Dave