Ratings for Wigan V Hull KR

[warrior till i die]

Richards was our standout player thought he was excellent to be honest, all the other backs where extremely poor except george carmont who scored 2 very good tries and phelpsy who worked hard and got stuck in. Calderwood, Goulding, Barrett and Leuluai where shocking. Leuluai couldnt stop kicking down the full backs throat and he was abysmal in attack (apart from his offload to carmont)

Both hookers were below average, higham in particular who was falling off tackles left right and centre. Coley and fielden i thought shown effort- fielden but some scorching hits in! Hocky was very good making solid yards and a couple of good line breaks, tomkins had a good first half but i didnt see him in the second half. colbon was average and lockers looked rusty in attack and ok in defence!

[mike binder]

if sts were 12 pts up after the first 5 mins of the first half ,they would of gone on to win with 50 pts or so,this team just cant finish games off and i beleive that that is a coaching problem not a player problem.

remember when wigan were losing to bradford last season and Nobles apprentice changed the tactics and go on to lose ,who do you think he learnt that off.

i realkly do beleive he takes the foot off the gas and he tries to save players till later on,but that tactic this dy and age dodnt work because its so hard to stopp a team on a roll ,except us we get on a roll and its all change and thats a coaching problem

[cpwigan]

The Wigan Evening Post gave Richard, Carmont and Coley 8. Calderwood, Goulding and Lu Lu 6 The rest got 7.

[cpwigan]

http://www.superleague.co.uk/page.php?id=479

[the-Bowtun-Warrior]

The Wigan Evening Post gave Richard, Carmont and Coley 8. Calderwood, Goulding and Lu Lu 6 The rest got 7.

about right for the WEP!

usual pap!

[topskin]

goulding not good enough cant tackle his way out of a paper bag

[topskin]

trouble with goulding he lets the attacker turn him round instead of moveing up to the tackle and meeting the player he lets this happen when he plays in the reserves in my oppinion he is carrying to much weight and is slow to make the tackle

[the-Bowtun-Warrior]

goulding not good enough cant tackle his way out of a paper bag

Unfair to single one player out.

well said.

[gpartin]

Pat Richards - 7
Mark Calderwood - 6
Darrell Goulding - 6
George Carmont - 8
Cameron Phelps - 6
Trent Barrett - 6
Thomas Leuluai - 6
Stuart Fielden - 8
Mickey Higham - 5
Andy Coley - 8
Harrison Hansen - 6
Joel Tomkins - 7
Gareth Hock - 8

---------------------------------------------

Michael McIlorum - 6
Feka Paleaasina ( did not look fit ) - 6
Liam Colbon - 6
Sean O'loughlin - 6



The bench did feck all for us.

Fieldens defence was crap, no way deserves an 8