WIGAN`S WORST SIGNING`S FIELDEN VAEILIKI DOC MURRY ?

[weststand-rich]

CP, like you I reckon Fielden is mentally shot, but that's not all his problem - at least half is physical. Physically he is much lighter than at his propping peak and his reduced strength and bulk mean he just cannot realise what he wants to do.

I believe I know why his physical prowess is not what it was, but posting that cogniscent theory is possibly libellous.

As a signing I would take the devils adovate position and even suggest he's not that bad. His stats are as good as Andy Coley (who I rate as a solid-to-good player), it's just his disproportionate salary that makes him appalling value.

[cpwigan]

He certainly had a far better conditioner in his early Bradford career.

[pedro]

see thats bad in anyones books.......1 game our for the season

[thegimble]

A woman cannot understand or experience what it is like for men to play v men in a physical contact sport because they are not male. It really is that simple. Anybody who has played league, union, football at any level can. You do not need to play SL, nor do you have to play RL. No male can understand what a woman goes through giving birth. It's just the way it is.

N.B There is a fantastic thread on Sam Tomkins. Funny how so called posters like Ellery prefer to whine about other posters rather than creat/post those threads. The only person in life that can make somebody feel inferior is YOU. Nobody else can make you feel inferior. However, it is far easier for people to blame others.

Cant believe how full much you really think of yourself i never said anything about inferiority. I dont blame anyone for anything just i cant be bothered with the forum for the last 6 months due to lack of respect sometimes shown to others with different opinions.

You have an axe to grind and as a bitter and twisted poster chose this thread when you could have posted in umpteen threads. I just lol when posters like you and Ellery complain about not being able to offer your opinions yet want to restrict others. Do we not have right of reply preferably constructively. If somebody disagrees with somebody in a reasoned matter then so be it. That is life. If it makes you feel so bad then you have far greater problems than internet forums.

Personally, I could not give a hoot what others think of me. I am happy with who I am and that is all anybody ever should be.

To start off with i dont have an axe to grind. And as for bitter and twisted i dont have any issues with you or anyother person on this board. Well maybe WNAC but thats and exception. Anyone has the right of reply and anyone can have an opinion, wether i agree with them or not. Sometimes its better to step away from the issue ratehr than confront everyone you disagree with.

And as for Paul Koloi i saw him in the world cup before we signed and he looked a great player. Then again i watched him for 15 minutes. Which was as much as his Wigan career lasted.

[ancientnloyal]

could one add Desi Williams to the list?

[cpwigan]

Not sure but IIRC poor Desi had a nightmare debut v Cas and that was it for him unfortunately.

[ancientnloyal]

Mathers
Moran
Fielden
McAvoy
Bibey
Hanley

[pedro]

Shem was the worst CP

[cpwigan]

the worrying thing about Shem was he even looked bad when we played Bath at union.

[GeoffN]

Not sure but IIRC poor Desi had a nightmare debut v Cas and that was it for him unfortunately.

I seem to remember his debut was a pretty decent performance against Quins, and the Cas disaster was his second game, but I could be wrong.