Ganson

[cumbria_warrior]

Riddel and roberts agreed, but phelps has been outstanding second half of this season at full back, yes coley has been hit n miss but still a decent player

[ian b]

Riddel and roberts agreed, but phelps has been outstanding second half of this season at full back, yes coley has been hit n miss but still a decent player

phelps is not good enough at fullback,please dont tell me you think he is

[cpwigan]

How many of you thought it was clever to shout we want Ganson blah blah. As it happens I do not think he cost Wigan the game but he did make a couple of bad errors.

[pedro]

Riddel and roberts agreed, but phelps has been outstanding second half of this season at full back, yes coley has been hit n miss but still a decent player

phelps is not good enough at fullback,please dont tell me you think he is

last night when it counted and against better opposition he proved he wasnt. Like IL says he may be good value but that shouldnt matter. If we had not have paid Doc Murray for playing he would have been good value but still wasnt good.

[wiganborn]

the 2 main people resonsible for this are the 2 LLs lenahan and lydon they bought second rate players and no doubt we are importing a second rate coach from australia time for both to move on and hand the club over to people that care about wigan :conf:

[waterside glens]

i thought he was ok ,he missed a few things both ways but off loading on 2nd tackle when your on a break and at stains 30 yard line done us more harm than ganson.

[mike binder]

i agree the guy is total shithead and loves himself but he didnt cost us the game wigan did it to themselves

Agreed. We are simply not good enough, the only way that will change is if we recruit three or four top class aussies and get rid of the dross we signed last year.

Let's not forget that we finished sixth in a very ordinary league!

officially we have finished 3rd as we have done for the last 3 seasons now

[mike binder]

the 2 main people resonsible for this are the 2 LLs lenahan and lydon they bought second rate players and no doubt we are importing a second rate coach from australia time for both to move on and hand the club over to people that care about wigan :conf:

lydon went at the start of the season ,not sure but think Mick Hogan replaced him ,and your sure cant complain about the efforts that Mick as put

[adiddy]

I know its not easy for the refs to see and award correctly, penalties that sometimes can win or lose a game for a team! But, and I hate myself for saying this and its the first time I have, Ganson gave away some extremely biased decisions last night! One which sticks in my mind is the supposed stripping of the ball in the first half which lead to longs try! The man didnt even see it and awarded the pen to stains! As there was only one other game in super league this weekend, a neutral ref should have been allocated end of!

Matt

[ian b]

I know its not easy for the refs to see and award correctly, penalties that sometimes can win or lose a game for a team! But, and I hate myself for saying this and its the first time I have, Ganson gave away some extremely biased decisions last night! One which sticks in my mind is the supposed stripping of the ball in the first half which lead to longs try! The man didnt even see it and awarded the pen to stains! As there was only one other game in super league this weekend, a neutral ref should have been allocated end of!

Matt

i reckon he is stupid and blind aswell and after watching the aussie final he should be shot the amount of times he goes to the video,he is a pratt.I think they they went twice in 80 mins this morning.