Re: Scully to face disciplanar...

[Doveoverdave]

After watching the incident a few times i still dont think scully has a case to answer

We will have to let the disciplinary panel decide. At best it was poor technique from Scully. He did connect and his tackler was taken from the field injured.The correct decision was made by the ref.

Watch that one again Rads was lucky not to have taken the full blow in the face.

If this is the same incident I am recalling. The Salford player did not commit a foul, the penalty was given for intent No arguements with that, but again if this had happenend with a Wiganer the offender you still would not be happy with the decision as you would be saying no contact was made!

Again the right decision by the ref.

Its just that you cannot see them through your cherry & white blinkers!

[robjoenz]

Doveoverdave posted:
Once again I find myself in agreement Rob. (AsI did with ref post).

I'm glad you've finally seen the light and come round to my way of thinking

[Doveoverdave]

robjoenz posted:

Doveoverdave posted:
Once again I find myself in agreement Rob. (AsI did with ref post).

I'm glad you've finally seen the light and come round to my way of thinking

Nice bit of editorial work Rob!

[warrior till i die]

Thats the way scully runs though even silverwood said it wernt a penalty offense. There was definetly no intention in the run. Also Coley went looking for everyone after that.

[wiresphs]

[/quote]we do get ripped off by all the merry blowers im lead to beleive they were all rugby fans when we were great now they are all out to destroy us because of the pain we inflicted on them when they were kids [/quote]
"Do you know, you could be right"! I for one would be sorely tempted to seek retribrution if i were the man in the middle, for reasons i need not explain!!!!

[waterside glens]

i thought the guy tried to bite scully,s elbow

[MrsLam]

I agree Waterside, I also noticed that he lowered his head, nudged Scullys elbow upwards and then banged it hard. Cheat!

[robjoenz]

MrsLam posted:
I agree Waterside, I also noticed that he lowered his head, nudged Scullys elbow upwards and then banged it hard. Cheat!

All these pesky players using the old sly low head tactic and claiming it's a high tackle!

[GeoffN]

See...it's not just the refs, even the disciplinary committee are out to get us!!

[MrsLam]

Are we making you feel like you're not alone yet Geoff?