Why are we persevering with this average bloke!

[Kittwazzer]

Logan on the bench BTW is a total waste of a spot. No reflection on him but he is either a starting player or not at all player. Hampshire, Williams would offer much more impact from the bench.

And all 3 would offer more than Green who has been shite since the Exiles game. Righty. Lefty. Middley. My Arsey. He's no bloody good!

[RobWigan]

Not sure who you are replying to Rob

BUT Matty Smith and Chase would be a great halfback combo for us and Tim Smith and Chase will be a very good one for Salford particularly if Smith has sorted his defence out which he seems to have.

I will say it here and now that Salford will reach a final in 2014, If they do Rob, you donate £10 to Mike for the website. If they do not, I will donate £10.

Make it 100 pound????? I will take that CpWigan and i will honour it

[TrueBlueWarrior]

What kind of rugby do you watch?? Every player mentioned would improve us greatly. And Sa'u is one of if not the best second rowers in the world.

Improving us does not make them 'great' players. I watch SL and NRL!!

Then you should know Sa'u is a great player as is Asotasi and Keating certainly isnt a poor player.

Im getting the impression your saying Keating isn't as good as Green. I think your twisting your words to suit your argument.

Not at all God, read the original post from Dave Highfive, he clearly said Wigan should be signing 'Great' foreign players, I responded by saying no team in SL is currently signing 'great' foreign players due to the money in the NRL. I never even mentioned players till he stated Meli and Chase hahaha, I said great foreign players are Cronk, Smith, Thaiday, Gallen, Slater, Marshall etc. I am not twisting any argument because I don't need to!!

[NeeNawWarrior22]

Why is George Williams being over looked? I didn't think he did too bad when given the opportunity.

[NeeNawWarrior22]

Not sure who you are replying to Rob

BUT Matty Smith and Chase would be a great halfback combo for us and Tim Smith and Chase will be a very good one for Salford particularly if Smith has sorted his defence out which he seems to have.

I will say it here and now that Salford will reach a final in 2014, If they do Rob, you donate £10 to Mike for the website. If they do not, I will donate £10.

Make it 100 pound????? I will take that CpWigan and i will honour it

Why 100? It's a cheeky bet with a friendly donation of 10, stick to 10. Just saying

[i'm spartacus]

The highlight of tonight's event for me, was the two girls eating fire before the game.

I was totally in awe of those two, and then a rugby match ruined what had been a totally pleasant experience up to that point. I was totally gutted when they didn't come back on at half time.

[sheepsteeth]

where was the line speed tonight? we stood still so they always made good yards and won collision to get quick ptb's.

we needed someone like Westwood tonight to fly out the traps and belt them. we made it far too easy.

without lockers Hampshire needs to play or at the very least sam needs to come in and take first receiver more because he's being starved of any decent ball!

[RobWigan]

Not sure who you are replying to Rob

BUT Matty Smith and Chase would be a great halfback combo for us and Tim Smith and Chase will be a very good one for Salford particularly if Smith has sorted his defence out which he seems to have.

I will say it here and now that Salford will reach a final in 2014, If they do Rob, you donate £10 to Mike for the website. If they do not, I will donate £10.

Make it 100 pound????? I will take that CpWigan and i will honour it

Why 100? It's a cheeky bet with a friendly donation of 10, stick to 10. Just saying

Hahah i am a betting man , but i will accept 20 pound CpWigan?

[gillysmyhero]

Chase is a match winner!

RE Green, a righty playing on the left because Wane bought two righty half backs! Not Greens fault. Now imagine Smith on the right and Chase on the left

Not selecting Hampshire on the bench is crazy BTW

So CP that could explain why Josh is starved of the ball and never gets a decent running chance and the ball goes out to pats wing a lot more.

[First Try Tickle]

Why does everyone seem to overlook Smith, what influence has on our game apart from the kick on the last. He shows loads of enthusiasm but simply doesn't have it. I think Green does have something but doesn't seem to be trying hard enough to show it.

And in defence of them both, there was a real lack of runners tonight.