Time for a divorse Mrs Carney

[jinkin jimmy]

Faz walked out on his contract and has left us in the sticky stuff. He would have been playing regularly now and a playoff place would have been a lot closer than it is at the moment

[adrenalinxx]

I think Carney wants to leave because of all the injuries that he has picked up.

Wigan signed him knowing that he wanted to go to the NRL and i'm sure that Carney was happy to stay at Wigan for the full term of his contract.

His recent injuries have changed all that:
Wigan don't want a player who keeps getting injured especially when alot of other players seem to get injured

Carney him self wants to play in the NRL, basically it's his live long dream but it could go badly wrong for him and hw knows it another injury might end is career in Rugby League.

So Carney could play another year for Wigan get injured and never play again or he could play for an NRL team get injured and never play again but atleast he would have played some Rugby in the NRL.

Imagen if you played for a Rugby League team and you were told that Wigan wanted to sign you but you had had some injuries and were worried about how long you have left playing. Wouldn't you leave even if you were under contract just so you could play for Wigan?

We shouldn't be annoyed at Carney he's played well for us (when he's played) but after all he's only human like us.

[WiganWarrior]

Im glad actually i wanted him to go when he first said he was going to see out his contract. He is too injury prone and it will free up money under the salary cap.

He doesnt want to play so i think we cut out losses and let him go

[waterside glens]

i would let him go now . he,s done nowt since he came back from injury so let him go. we are reasonably safe now so lets give the likes of colbon a few games

[trotski_tgwu]

waterside glens posted:
i would let him go now . he,s done nowt since he came back from injury so let him go. we are reasonably safe now so lets give the likes of colbon a few games

Well said M8 Nice to see you are still with us


And on a lighter note my Daughter Ticklelass Meet her Hero on Saturday Night & has been on cloud nine ever since lol

I must say Danny is a really nice guy as he took time out for Autographs shirt signing & pics.

A True Wigan Player

[DaveO]

adrenalinxx posted:
I think Carney wants to leave because of all the injuries that he has picked up.

Wigan signed him knowing that he wanted to go to the NRL and i'm sure that Carney was happy to stay at Wigan for the full term of his contract.

His recent injuries have changed all that:
Wigan don't want a player who keeps getting injured especially when alot of other players seem to get injured

What do you mean? If everytime a player got a serious injury we got rid we would not have had Farrell last season and Radlinski would have left last week.

Dallas wold have gone about two seasons ago as well!

You have to assume players will get over their injuries and play for you again given the fact you can't just rip up their contracts.

Carney him self wants to play in the NRL, basically it's his live long dream but it could go badly wrong for him and hw knows it another injury might end is career in Rugby League.

And he could walk under a bus tomorrow. That is life. He has made a commitment to Wigan and he should get on with the job.

Are Wigan supposed to wrap him cotton wool so he can have a pop at the NRL? He is being paid to do a job and if he doesn't do it we are yet another player down who we expected to have available for 2006.

Do you think the club can rustle up a replacement just like that? They will be planning one for 2007 but the idea Wigan is some sort of kindergarden for players with ambitions elsewhere is nuts.

So Carney could play another year for Wigan get injured and never play again or he could play for an NRL team get injured and never play again but atleast he would have played some Rugby in the NRL.

SO WHAT !!! Wigan are not a charity but an RL club still in danger of getting relegated and this twit is spouting on about playing for another club. Not once does he mention our situation.

He wouldn't be in the position he is in today if he hadn't played for us.

Imagen if you played for a Rugby League team and you were told that Wigan wanted to sign you but you had had some injuries and were worried about how long you have left playing. Wouldn't you leave even if you were under contract just so you could play for Wigan?

Don't be so flippin' stupid. This is real life not Roy of the Rovers (wrong sport but you get my drift hopefully). He can't just "leave". Wigan have to release him form his contract.

Why should they do that? If Newcastle want him while under contract they should pay a fee. The snag with that is I don't think there is an international agreement regarding transfer fees so we get nothing.

We shouldn't be annoyed at Carney he's played well for us (when he's played) but after all he's only human like us.

What complete and utter nonsense!

You think talking about getting out of a freely entered into contract while we are struggling is not something to get annoyed about?

He has signed a contract for two years with Gold Coast in 2007 but wants to go and get the crap knocked out of him for another team in the NRL first rather than see out his career here?

He isn't even going to play for his team from 2007. Given his comments about wanting to play with Johns if I were CEO of Gold Coast or whatever they are called I'd be questioning his committment to that.

He has his wish to play in the NRL as of 2007. He should honour his contract until then, plain and simple.

Dave

[thegimble]

damien morrissey posted:
Difference between Faz and the traitor is that Faz gave us years of world class performances has moved to another albeit linked sport.He hasnt moved away from the club he has changed sport.The only thing that wound me up was seeing his face all round the technical area and shouting orders out at training,if your gonna go go. Carney has grown a huuuge ego and forgotten to transfer that to the pitch.His knees hard compact aussie fields he will be how do the aussies put it CROOK in no time.I dont wish any player to be injured but i think that this is inevitable.

No thats crap Faz did exactly the same as BC both are well paid and well looked after.

They both left a sinking ship. Just like Michael Owen who left LFC to go to Madrid lets win the big one next year and rub it in thier disloyal faces.

[Exiled Wiganer]

Both faz and BC are looking after number one, rather than considering the best interests of the club. Faz, though, left our sport, whereas BC is looking to test himself in league in Oz.That's a point in BC's favour for mine. We cannot expect loyalty from him - he wasn't a Wigan junior, he's Irish, and knows that time is not on his side.

As for his injuries, we just don't know how bad they have been - it might be the case that they have been bad, and taken their toll on him. We can't say for certain that isn't the case.

If we can replace him with someone younger and keener, let him go.

[DaveO]

Exiled Wiganer posted:
Both faz and BC are looking after number one, rather than considering the best interests of the club. Faz, though, left our sport, whereas BC is looking to test himself in league in Oz.

That was all arranged and due to start in 2007. I had no problem with that.

Wanting to get out of his contract here early to play for another RL club for one season is very poor anf unprofessional behaviour.

We cannot expect loyalty from him - he wasn't a Wigan junior, he's Irish, and knows that time is not on his side.

It is not loyalty but professionalism that is lacking with Brian Carney.

If we can replace him with someone younger and keener, let him go.

Well according to the Aussie on-line press he has indeed agreed to join Newcastle for a season and this has been announced by them.

Personally I think he should agree to leave the club now as there is no place in the team for players not interested in playing for it. Players like Richards in Australia are being totally professional about their last season in the NRL before coming here. Is Richards worried about getting crocked before coming here? No, he is giving his all as he should do. The same applies to Fletcher who is older than Carney and could miss out on his two year retirement fund if anything happened injury wise (aka Davico).

I have lost all respect for Carney due to him going public with various statemts about wantingto leave when the club is still not out of the woods yet.

This quote comes from the BBC web site where he refers to the town of Newcastle:

"The whole area supports the team," he said.

Well isn't that a slap in the face for all the supporters of Wigan one of the best supported teams in the game, who have stuck by him through his injuries.

Dave

[thegimble]

DaveO posted:

Exiled Wiganer posted:
Both faz and BC are looking after number one, rather than considering the best interests of the club. Faz, though, left our sport, whereas BC is looking to test himself in league in Oz.

That was all arranged and due to start in 2007. I had no problem with that.

Wanting to get out of his contract here early to play for another RL club for one season is very poor anf unprofessional behaviour.

We cannot expect loyalty from him - he wasn't a Wigan junior, he's Irish, and knows that time is not on his side.

It is not loyalty but professionalism that is lacking with Brian Carney.

If we can replace him with someone younger and keener, let him go.

Well according to the Aussie on-line press he has indeed agreed to join Newcastle for a season and this has been announced by them.

Personally I think he should agree to leave the club now as there is no place in the team for players not interested in playing for it. Players like Richards in Australia are being totally professional about their last season in the NRL before coming here. Is Richards worried about getting crocked before coming here? No, he is giving his all as he should do. The same applies to Fletcher who is older than Carney and could miss out on his two year retirement fund if anything happened injury wise (aka Davico).

I have lost all respect for Carney due to him going public with various statemts about wantingto leave when the club is still not out of the woods yet.

This quote comes from the BBC web site where he refers to the town of Newcastle:

"The whole area supports the team," he said.

Well isn't that a slap in the face for all the supporters of Wigan one of the best supported teams in the game, who have stuck by him through his injuries.

Dave

We should not play him again this season and let him train with the academy sides.