Charnley or Micky Mc

[Alreetas]

I think MM is more valuable and a lot harder to replace, don't get me wrong with both we are a stronger team but MM in my opinion is a more rounded player.

[josie andrews]

Ask CP Josie tell him I said ok to confide with you, but I would ask that you stop questioning my posts every time, or I will stop posting, and that would be not fair to the rest of the supporters on here. Josh is a young guy who needs the club to guide him at this time in his career, its easily to have ex coaches promising the earth to impressionable young players.

If it was a rumour then I would have put it on that site

I was just asking, I wasn't trying to be argumentative or else I wouldnt have put 'thanks' at the end of my post.

Sorry if you got the wrong impression

Can you give me an example of when I have questioned your posts everytime, please?

Thanks

[josie andrews]

Can you provide proof? Thanks

I'm not sure these "prove it" type posts are particularly useful. What sort of proof can posters realistically provide?

When reading an internet board I think people are capable of forming opinions based on the knowledge that not all "facts" are in fact facts. You need to use your experience of the world and maybe some knowledge about the poster of the message to judge if you think the "fact" is reliable or not.

Threads that degenerate into an arguments about the sources of information are pretty boring and pointless IMO.

I wasn't being argumentative Mike, I was just asking. I thought I may have missed something while I've been away

[chnwh]

Micky.

Burgess and Manfredi would be a superb wing partnership.

[Kaii]

We don't need to choose we have both, if it was Lockers vs any other Wigan player then it would be an easy choice

As for wing partnerships Burgess & Charnley will be the best in super league by far, Joe's try on Sunday he shown the strength that Pat had and speed close to Charnley's. Exciting time ahead add in Rocky, Dan, Sam, the Scott & Eddy partnership it will only get better. That's even before you get to a big stronger ginger pearl and Bateman

[KOOCH]

Pointless post.

[Kittwazzer]

Pointless post.

:eusa2:

[Wigan_forever1985]

Pointless post.

no it isn't

this is a forum for debate, this is relevant to Wigan and there was talk of both of these players leaving for the NRL in the rumour mill

If you do not wish to participate in the debate then ok, quite ironic that there is much less point in writing "pointless post"

[KaylaRobbo]

Pointless I know but - can we not just keep both?!?!?! Sad day to think about losing any. It doesn't feel great to be a breeding nursery for the 'super' NRL. Let them grow their own!!!!

[Kaii]

http://www.manchestereveningnews.co.uk/ ... ay-6777197

Rumour killed, tbh most people knew this and didn't believe the rubbish spouted on different social media