Best overseas signing, biggest overseas flop?

[TrueBlueWarrior]

I thought Trent Barrett was awesome for us in a team in transition. He was robbed of the man of steel award by Roby who played 90% of his games that season starting on the bench. Trent would be awesome in our current set up.

Meds is being mischievous I think booze!!

[jobo]

Without a doubt Brett Kenny the BEST!!

By a country mile.

[jobo]

Graham West, Greg Dowling, Kevin Iro, even Sam Panapa didn't do too bad either.

[medlocke]

George Carmont best

Brady Malam worst

Inga or Henry Paul union convert

[cpwigan]

Luke Davico - worst.

[Kittwazzer]

I thought Trent Barrett was awesome for us in a team in transition. He was robbed of the man of steel award by Roby who played 90% of his games that season starting on the bench. Trent would be awesome in our current set up.

Meds is being mischievous I think booze!!

He's entitled to his opinion though and he does have a point to the extent that, despite any player's ability, paying him a quarter of the entire salary cap does not bode well for dressing room harmony. Thankfully with IL in charge, that scenario will not happen again!

[RobWigan]

Makes me laugh when some people say GREAT wigan players when they have only been at the club ONE season, tge greatest players are the ones that are at the club long term

[cpwigan]

I think it depends. Plenty played season after season yet never had the impact another player had in a single season.

I think Saints fans describe Mal Meninga as a great Saint, a legendary Saint YET he was only there for a season. Likewise, Brett Kenny and John Ferguson for us. To be honest there are so many more. One of my favourite players spent more time at Wire but he had a great single season for us; Phil Blake.

[Wigan_forever1985]

I think it depends. Plenty played season after season yet never had the impact another player had in a single season.

I think Saints fans describe Mal Meninga as a great Saint, a legendary Saint YET he was only there for a season. Likewise, Brett Kenny and John Ferguson for us. To be honest there are so many more. One of my favourite players spent more time at Wire but he had a great single season for us; Phil Blake.

this is why I went for carmont I suppose its how you define "best" do you define it as contribution to the club overall, in the sense Richards and Carmont would be up there, or the biggest talent/name in that sense you look at Kenny and Barrett.

Same for worst, I like you was going to go for luke davico but then I thought is that fair he ws injured in the warm up game and never played. DV played badly for all but his last season.

[DaveO]

Best: Dean Bell

Not only a top class player but here for a long time. I think he is very underrated in terms of how good he was ironically because he was here a long time. I think we ended up taking his skills for granted.

Worst: DV

Best Union convert:

Frano.