Hooker
-
- Posts: 3252
- Joined: Fri Apr 25, 2014 9:31 pm
Re: Hooker
Don't agree.
Should Micky get injured or suspended, of which he has had a few of both over the past few years, we need a 9 who can fit in and do a good job for us.
Logan can do that and also if needed he can also do 80 mins. IMO we need to keep our options open and available.
IMO I'd like to see MM do 80 mins v saints and Logan 80 v Salford! Just to be awkward of course!
Should Micky get injured or suspended, of which he has had a few of both over the past few years, we need a 9 who can fit in and do a good job for us.
Logan can do that and also if needed he can also do 80 mins. IMO we need to keep our options open and available.
IMO I'd like to see MM do 80 mins v saints and Logan 80 v Salford! Just to be awkward of course!
-
- Posts: 715
- Joined: Tue Apr 19, 2005 9:52 pm
Re: Hooker
i think Logan needs to be given a fresh slate by some, IMO he can shine for us
we don't stop playing because we grow old ....... we grow old because we stop playing
Re: Hooker
Logan not worth of a place on bench for Friday micky Mac will give Roby nightmares on Friday that's if he plays
Tomkins was very average against wakey his speed of thought and decision making is average at best
Tomkins was very average against wakey his speed of thought and decision making is average at best
Re: Hooker
Short Memories
Shaun Wane played MM for the 80 on numerous occasions in his first season in charge, but he was burnt out by the play offs.
Since then he has managed him much better throughout the season. Come the play offs or certainly the GF I expect Wane will play him for the 80 mins and use that spare bench spot for a back/back rower.
Shaun Wane played MM for the 80 on numerous occasions in his first season in charge, but he was burnt out by the play offs.
Since then he has managed him much better throughout the season. Come the play offs or certainly the GF I expect Wane will play him for the 80 mins and use that spare bench spot for a back/back rower.
Re: Hooker
Mac works hard particularly in defence but the quality is not there more than ever particularly in attack so the resting is not work. In a recent game for the first time IMO Logan had a positive impact replacing Mac which whilst Logan has busted a gut to improve says more about Mac than Logan.
- superleague
- Posts: 1766
- Joined: Mon Mar 07, 2005 9:38 pm
Re: Hooker
I've personally never really rated Mac always thought he was such a limited number 9, average distribution, no pace, and not the cleverest upstairs especially rugby brain wisecpwigan wrote:Mac works hard particularly in defence but the quality is not there more than ever particularly in attack so the resting is not work. In a recent game for the first time IMO Logan had a positive impact replacing Mac which whilst Logan has busted a gut to improve says more about Mac than Logan.
- TrueBlueWarrior
- Posts: 6171
- Joined: Wed May 25, 2011 10:17 pm
Re: Hooker
Do you rate Roby?superleague wrote:I've personally never really rated Mac always thought he was such a limited number 9, average distribution, no pace, and not the cleverest upstairs especially rugby brain wisecpwigan wrote:Mac works hard particularly in defence but the quality is not there more than ever particularly in attack so the resting is not work. In a recent game for the first time IMO Logan had a positive impact replacing Mac which whilst Logan has busted a gut to improve says more about Mac than Logan.
'If you start listening to the fans it won't be long before you're sitting with them.' - Wayne Bennett
-
- Posts: 6338
- Joined: Thu Jul 03, 2008 2:08 pm
Re: Hooker
I do, I wish Wigan had signed him as a junior. I think he is one of the few hookers of his generation who could have made it in the NRL.TrueBlueWarrior wrote:Do you rate Roby?superleague wrote:I've personally never really rated Mac always thought he was such a limited number 9, average distribution, no pace, and not the cleverest upstairs especially rugby brain wisecpwigan wrote:Mac works hard particularly in defence but the quality is not there more than ever particularly in attack so the resting is not work. In a recent game for the first time IMO Logan had a positive impact replacing Mac which whilst Logan has busted a gut to improve says more about Mac than Logan.
Winning is down to 99% perspiration and 1% inspiration - Shaun Edwards
- TrueBlueWarrior
- Posts: 6171
- Joined: Wed May 25, 2011 10:17 pm
Re: Hooker
....and yet MM consistently outplays him!!shaunedwardsfanclub wrote:I do, I wish Wigan had signed him as a junior. I think he is one of the few hookers of his generation who could have made it in the NRL.TrueBlueWarrior wrote:Do you rate Roby?superleague wrote: I've personally never really rated Mac always thought he was such a limited number 9, average distribution, no pace, and not the cleverest upstairs especially rugby brain wise
'If you start listening to the fans it won't be long before you're sitting with them.' - Wayne Bennett
- superleague
- Posts: 1766
- Joined: Mon Mar 07, 2005 9:38 pm
Re: Hooker
TrueBlueWarrior wrote:I kinda understand what you mean but hookers don't directly play against one another like centre vs centre for example. But I think he's looked the more dominate in the past due to out pack being on top and us dominating, but comparing talent vs talent Roby is the better player hands down IMOshaunedwardsfanclub wrote:I do, I wish Wigan had signed him as a junior. I think he is one of the few hookers of his generation who could have made it in the NRL.TrueBlueWarrior wrote: Do you rate Roby?
....and yet MM consistently outplays him!!