Is Wane the right man to coach Wigan?

[DaveO]

By whom?

A question as daft as that doesn't deserve an answer - and you know exactly what I mean by that.

Yes. You don't have one!

And if he got sacked tomorrow, neither would you!

The "by whom" argument is the most weak and feeble one going. Was anyone on here suggesting Madge replace Noble?

No, but there were plenty saying Noble was past his sell by date.

I didn't think I'd have to spell it out.

[the sully bar]

With the team we have we should be at the very least looking at the quarters in my view but things happen in the cup and we was turned over nothing more to say ,on the day we played poor they played smart .

[DaveO]

With the team we have we should be at the very least looking at the quarters in my view but things happen in the cup and we was turned over nothing more to say ,on the day we played poor they played smart .

But that is two years in a row this has happened.

That is not good enough for a team with our resources.

[Kittwazzer]

A question as daft as that doesn't deserve an answer - and you know exactly what I mean by that.

Yes. You don't have one!

And if he got sacked tomorrow, neither would you!

The "by whom" argument is the most weak and feeble one going. Was anyone on here suggesting Madge replace Noble?

No, but there were plenty saying Noble was past his sell by date.

I didn't think I'd have to spell it out.

Well you did and I thank you for it.
So who do you have lined up as our next Madge, an unknown Assistant NRL Coach who was initially pilloried on here as someone IFL had hired on the cheap?
BTW don't forget Saints tried to copy our example when they hired Royce!

[Panchitta Marra]

Obviously my vote is NO what say others?

:slee: :slee:

[the sully bar]

It happends Dave we smash teams at the dw and lose to poor teams away yet play the same game ? something is wrong and i cant put my finger on it ,we have won one away game in how many now ? yet 15 on the bounce at home , watching our performance tonight if i was a neutral i would of swear the wigan lads had had a bet on hull kr to win the odds were that good :conf:

[DaveO]

Well you did and I thank you for it.
So who do you have lined up as our next Madge, an unknown Assistant NRL Coach who was initially pilloried on here as someone IFL had hired on the cheap?
BTW don't forget Saints tried to copy our example when they hired Royce!

I haven't got anyone lined up. It's IL's job to sort that one out.

I don't see why that precludes us from recognising, as we did with Noble, when a coach isn't good enough.

If I said who I'd like to replace Wane if he got the boot all I'd get is "No chance, he's not available" whether anyone knows if he is or not.

Sam Tomkins "wasn't available" a few weeks ago.

One thing is certain. One day Wane will leave Wigan. And what will interest me is who IL goes for to replace him. Will IL be able to do as Mo did and persuade a modern day John Monie to come to Wigan or will he find another Madge?

I think the cheap/lazy option of appointing the assistant isn't possible next time.

[Kittwazzer]

The cheap/lazy option has won a LLS GF CCF in less time that Noble ran the show. They don't compare

[cpwigan]

Why do posters not grow a set, pardon the pun Josie BUT you either believe Wane is the right man to coach Wigan or not.

I simply said no. Others have said no. If you think yes say yes! NOT difficult

We have only lost early in the CC for the second successive year, we only now have the GF to avoid 2 empty years. If you think Yes say yes, if not say No.

[the sully bar]

Why do posters not grow a set, pardon the pun Josie BUT you either believe Wane is the right man to coach Wigan or not.

I simply said no. Others have said no. If you think yes say yes! NOT difficult

We have only lost early in the CC for the second successive year, we only now have the GF to avoid 2 empty years. If you think Yes say yes, if not say No.

Ok so lets put this another way , our current position in the league looking forward to the future who is avalable who would you have lead us cp if not wane at this moment in time ? and for the record i say yes he is the right coach for the job at this time .