Is Super League Rigged?
-
TrueBlueWarrior
- Posts: 6171
- Joined: Wed May 25, 2011 10:17 pm
Re: Is Super League Rigged?
After last night, it's clearly rigged!!
'If you start listening to the fans it won't be long before you're sitting with them.' - Wayne Bennett
-
stevethegas
- Posts: 487
- Joined: Sat Aug 12, 2006 11:33 am
Re: Is Super League Rigged?
I maintain, as earlier, that the league isn't rigged. But after the debacle of Clubb's (non) try at Wembley we saw last night another rubbish decision.
Clearly the Sky commentators don't have the freedom to criticise as perhaps they would like to. But it seems the BBC's experts were less reticent. They clearly thought the decision over the Wembley try was a bad one.
And so to Ben Barba's "try" at St. Helens
The similarities with Tony Clubb's are screaming the need for a review of how to use the video ref.
In both cases a ball is lost over the line, then touched down.
OK, my vested interest is as a true Wigan fan. But Barba lost the ball and it went forward before he touched it. Clubb had the ball pulled out and it went backwards. Then knocked forward by the Hull tackler and then touched down.
But the onfield ref gave a decision which was wrong in both cases and was allowed to stand.
So why bother with the video ref? If they can't use common sense they shouldn't be there at all. Had neither match been on television and we'd had in goal judges as we do for the other games, would the decision be the same? I wonder.
So, no, it's not rigged. But it's a mess that really needs to be addressed. What we have at present just isn't good enough.
The video ref as we have it today is not fit for purpose because the rules are too restrictive and hide bound.
Clearly the Sky commentators don't have the freedom to criticise as perhaps they would like to. But it seems the BBC's experts were less reticent. They clearly thought the decision over the Wembley try was a bad one.
And so to Ben Barba's "try" at St. Helens
The similarities with Tony Clubb's are screaming the need for a review of how to use the video ref.
In both cases a ball is lost over the line, then touched down.
OK, my vested interest is as a true Wigan fan. But Barba lost the ball and it went forward before he touched it. Clubb had the ball pulled out and it went backwards. Then knocked forward by the Hull tackler and then touched down.
But the onfield ref gave a decision which was wrong in both cases and was allowed to stand.
So why bother with the video ref? If they can't use common sense they shouldn't be there at all. Had neither match been on television and we'd had in goal judges as we do for the other games, would the decision be the same? I wonder.
So, no, it's not rigged. But it's a mess that really needs to be addressed. What we have at present just isn't good enough.
The video ref as we have it today is not fit for purpose because the rules are too restrictive and hide bound.
Stevethegas
-
TrueBlueWarrior
- Posts: 6171
- Joined: Wed May 25, 2011 10:17 pm
Re: Is Super League Rigged?
Eddie on commentary last night was nothing short of disgraceful!
'If you start listening to the fans it won't be long before you're sitting with them.' - Wayne Bennett
-
nellywelly
- Posts: 270
- Joined: Sun Dec 11, 2005 10:38 am
Re: Is Super League Rigged?
Nothing ever changes he has always been biased against Wigan,at least Stevo had a reason to hate Wigan which goes back to when playing in Aus a ex wigan great decked him and I believe they were playing for the same side. From then on he hated everything to do with Wigan perhaps this hate has influenced Eddie into being biased against Wigan. It is best to watch sky with the sound turned downTrueBlueWarrior wrote:Eddie on commentary last night was nothing short of disgraceful!
Re: Is Super League Rigged?
He was still good friends with Bill after thatnellywelly wrote:Nothing ever changes he has always been biased against Wigan,at least Stevo had a reason to hate Wigan which goes back to when playing in Aus a ex wigan great decked him and I believe they were playing for the same side. From then on he hated everything to do with Wigan perhaps this hate has influenced Eddie into being biased against Wigan. It is best to watch sky with the sound turned downTrueBlueWarrior wrote:Eddie on commentary last night was nothing short of disgraceful!
-
Billgreenwoodsson
- Posts: 38
- Joined: Mon Oct 12, 2015 9:05 am
Re: Is Super League Rigged?
To my mind it is pure and simple. If the referee is unsure whether it is a try or not how the hell can he take a guess? Simple. Refer it to the video ref and let him look at anything he feels will help him get right decision. OR simply abandon the video ref idea on the basis that most matches do not have a vid ref so its not a level playing field!!!