Sarginson

[medlocke]

You are right again meds.Wish we could find a Garry Connoly or a Inga those where the days

I would be happy with a George Carmont

Goulding for me. Always thought he was very underrated and played well above his weight.

Thought he was a solid centre who did the basics right.

Was never a fan, Always thought he was a bit of a glory hound, Wanting to score the winning try rather than pass to his winger, But that's just me, However he would be vastly superior to Sargey

[pedro]

Goulding was a great centre

[jobo]

Goulding was a great centre

+1

[Firestarter]

Goulding was good because we had halves and a fullback who could attack and create down that side( something we really struggle to do with our current players).......... going back to the sarge/ gels thing........ i saw hardaker beat a man and outpace the defence,at salford....... something that gels or sarge never do...... he was also better than both defensively

[DaveO]

Gelling would fit in any SL side. He isnt as bad as some people try to claim.

No he wouldn’t and yes he is as bad as people make out. He came as a project player and he made zero improvement for all his time here.

His brain farts were ridiculous at times. If we had him now given the way our defence is all over the place his regular shooting out of the line and missing would have cost us more points conceded of that I am certain. Attack wise he rarely looked good against the better teams and it is against them he’d do something stupid as he tried to make up for the fact he was getting nowhere in general.

Him walking out on us was no loss. If we really went for him again the club was being stupid. Apart from the fact he just isn’t good enough to warrant the interest the way he left with claims his girlfriends car accident meant he had to return to NZ such that he needed releasing from his Wigan contract was just untrue. She was a bit battered and bruised not at deaths door. He basically walked out and so his bridges should have been well and truly burnt.

It would not however surprise me if he was offered a place. It’s the kind of lazy recruitment that lumbered us with Sarge when Gelling walked out Wigan now engage in.

[nathan_rugby]

I would be happy with a George Carmont

Goulding for me. Always thought he was very underrated and played well above his weight.

Thought he was a solid centre who did the basics right.

Was never a fan, Always thought he was a bit of a glory hound, Wanting to score the winning try rather than pass to his winger, But that's just me, However he would be vastly superior to Sargey

Would be interesting to see his try and assist record when he was a first team player. From memory I disagree with your point.

[Caboosegg]

Goulding for me. Always thought he was very underrated and played well above his weight.

Thought he was a solid centre who did the basics right.

Was never a fan, Always thought he was a bit of a glory hound, Wanting to score the winning try rather than pass to his winger, But that's just me, However he would be vastly superior to Sargey

Would be interesting to see his try and assist record when he was a first team player. From memory I disagree with your point.

I believe Charnley owed alot of his tries to the goulding partnership.

[medlocke]

Was never a fan, Always thought he was a bit of a glory hound, Wanting to score the winning try rather than pass to his winger, But that's just me, However he would be vastly superior to Sargey

Would be interesting to see his try and assist record when he was a first team player. From memory I disagree with your point.

I believe Charnley owed alot of his tries to the goulding partnership.

Ah, That old argument, Are you sure it wasn't down to Sam Tomkins

[pedro]

Would be interesting to see his try and assist record when he was a first team player. From memory I disagree with your point.

I believe Charnley owed alot of his tries to the goulding partnership.

Ah, That old argument, Are you sure it wasn't down to Sam Tomkins

nope deffo Goulding

[medlocke]

I believe Charnley owed alot of his tries to the goulding partnership.

Ah, That old argument, Are you sure it wasn't down to Sam Tomkins

nope deffo Goulding

Was deffo Tomkins, Many posters on here at the time came to the same conclusion, That's when I read it first