THE SCOREBOARD LOOKS CRUEL

[Richymac]

Danny McGuire in the studio at half time was such a poor choice. The commentary on the whole wasn’t terrible but needs less sweeping statements. More analysis... Jon Wilkin, Brian Noble, Dave Woods all offer much better insight than most of the Sky lot.

[Nezza Faz]

Danny McGuire in the studio at half time was such a poor choice. The commentary on the whole wasn’t terrible but needs less sweeping statements. More analysis... Jon Wilkin, Brian Noble, Dave Woods all offer much better insight than most of the Sky lot.

Why ??
I thought he was insightful and added some good punditry without showing any bias (he's at HKR these days, anyway !) and added quality entertainment value. He also gave an update on his mates health, Rob Burrow - nothing wrong with that.

[moto748]

Yes, for better or worse, McGuire and Wilkin are probably the best ex-player pundits (yeah I know he's still at Hull KR). However, the commentary itself was entirely centred around the game from Leeds' point of view. And if it was Radio Leeds, I'd say, fair enough. But this is a national broadcaster.

But I watched the brief SLS highlights earlier. For Manfredi's try, Wigan's handling was "as slick as an oilfield"! We don't get compliments like that on Sky!

[Mike]

We do though. They complimented our handling for that try highly and several times.

[Richymac]

Danny McGuire in the studio at half time was such a poor choice. The commentary on the whole wasn’t terrible but needs less sweeping statements. More analysis... Jon Wilkin, Brian Noble, Dave Woods all offer much better insight than most of the Sky lot.

Why ??
I thought he was insightful and added some good punditry without showing any bias (he's at HKR these days, anyway !) and added quality entertainment value. He also gave an update on his mates health, Rob Burrow - nothing wrong with that.

I just didn't like his analysis of Briscoe's try. I thought his analysis wasn't as good as Wilkin's has or any of the others that I mentioned. Just my opinion though. I think of it like how I don't watch Piers Morgan on ITV because I don't like his style. Just preference isn't it. Again, merely my opinion.

[moto748]

We do though. They complimented our handling for that try highly and several times.

Then we'll have agree to differ. They certainly did praise that handling, and rightly so, but the purple prose only seems to come out for Leeds or Saints.

[jaws1]

If you think that commentary is biased any one with Wigan TV watch the Saints v Wigan Good Friday match 2010 the 1st year of Maguire .Eddie and Stevo were so biased at slagging Wigan off and praising Saints it was embarrassing.
Incidentally from that match 11 years ago there is still players playing.
O'Loughlin
Tommy
Sam Tomkins
Joel Tomkins
Micky Mac
Mossop
Roby
Graham
Roby
Wilkin (Toronto)