Mago to Wakefield/Featherstone??

[wgwr1999]

Surely the expected first chance goes to Harvie Hill?

[pedro]

How is it any different to Tommy not counting on the quota last year?

In fact there is probably more of a case for Lam to be off quota than Tommy.

I think its because he was playing full time here at 19, it was said "a player who was not trained by an RLEF (Rugby League European Federation) member club for three years before the age of 21" , I dont think they thought people would challenge them on being st pats u14's

[Charriots Offiah]

How is it any different to Tommy not counting on the quota last year?

In fact there is probably more of a case for Lam to be off quota than Tommy.

I think its because he was playing full time here at 19, it was said "a player who was not trained by an RLEF (Rugby League European Federation) member club for three years before the age of 21" , I dont think they thought people would challenge them on being st pats u14's

The rule is not fit for purpose, change it.

[widdenoldboy]

How is it any different to Tommy not counting on the quota last year?

In fact there is probably more of a case for Lam to be off quota than Tommy.

I think its because he was playing full time here at 19, it was said "a player who was not trained by an RLEF (Rugby League European Federation) member club for three years before the age of 21" , I dont think they thought people would challenge them on being st pats u14's

The rule is not fit for purpose, change it.

Tommy was given some sort of dispensation, seeing that this forum has many people who follow the game closely and we aren't 100% sure how it works

[PeteG1988]

Yorkshire Saint on twitter recons JWH is going to Catalan. Claims he spoke to him after a game.

[Dreamteam]

One thing for sure is we’ve admitted mago was a bad signing. Ellis is in the failed section atm. Thornley can have his own section. How come saints have barely made a bad signing in the last 5 years. Who’s identifying some of these players. Ellis was poor at dragons. Thornley awful at Leigh as well. Miski takes a quota for a back up winger ??

[widdenoldboy]

One thing for sure is we’ve admitted mago was a bad signing. Ellis is in the failed section atm. Thornley can have his own section. How come saints have barely made a bad signing in the last 5 years. Who’s identifying some of these players. Ellis was poor at dragons. Thornley awful at Leigh as well. Miski takes a quota for a back up winger ??

Pretty much agree with these assesments.

[nathan_rugby]

One thing for sure is we’ve admitted mago was a bad signing. Ellis is in the failed section atm. Thornley can have his own section. How come saints have barely made a bad signing in the last 5 years. Who’s identifying some of these players. Ellis was poor at dragons. Thornley awful at Leigh as well. Miski takes a quota for a back up winger ??

Hopoate been a good signing has he?

[widdenoldboy]

One thing for sure is we’ve admitted mago was a bad signing. Ellis is in the failed section atm. Thornley can have his own section. How come saints have barely made a bad signing in the last 5 years. Who’s identifying some of these players. Ellis was poor at dragons. Thornley awful at Leigh as well. Miski takes a quota for a back up winger ??

Hopoate been a good signing has he?

Seemed to be carrying an injury from the start TBH. At least Thornly got injured after a couple of good games. Mago has had some good moments but too few, Ellis has been been OK in a few games, never outstanding. For balance, French and Field have bee very good and Cust has been solid.

[Dreamteam]

One thing for sure is we’ve admitted mago was a bad signing. Ellis is in the failed section atm. Thornley can have his own section. How come saints have barely made a bad signing in the last 5 years. Who’s identifying some of these players. Ellis was poor at dragons. Thornley awful at Leigh as well. Miski takes a quota for a back up winger ??

Hopoate been a good signing has he?

Never rated him myself anyway but had a good game vs us at magic. That’s 1 questionable signing