Oliver gildart
-
- Posts: 528
- Joined: Sun Jan 27, 2019 9:42 pm
Re: Oliver gildart
For me King has been the more impressive of the two new centres. It just seems like every time a try gets scored on an edge the blame gets put on the centre or winger because they are the ones that end up with the three on two overlap to contend with. The centre will pretty much always rush out of the line when the overlap is already there to try to force the passer into making an error. But when it doesn't come off the centre or winger gets the blame for the try being scored.
I've seen loads of criticism about King's defence but our right edge issues this year have largely come from poor movement in field that allows an overlap as soon as the ball is passed from the ruck. If we're pointing fingers then Pearce-Paul and Cust have been far more culpable than King. There's been some poor communication there, slow movement across the field and Cust in particular seems to have a tendency to turn inwards and plant his feet.
King's carries have been impressive and his work rate can't be questioned. He's doing the work of a forward which is what we really didn't get from Bibby (and weirdly, Isa and KPP when in that role). Sure, he's not created many tries for French but that seems to be more of a team issue. When he's got the chance to put French into the clear he has done, but it's not been as frequent this season. If we were creating the space but ignoring the opportunities I'd be more concerned about King, but we're not as fluid in attack down the right edge and that's as much to do with Cust, Isa/KPP and Field because they are the ones that need to create the space to create chances.
I've seen loads of criticism about King's defence but our right edge issues this year have largely come from poor movement in field that allows an overlap as soon as the ball is passed from the ruck. If we're pointing fingers then Pearce-Paul and Cust have been far more culpable than King. There's been some poor communication there, slow movement across the field and Cust in particular seems to have a tendency to turn inwards and plant his feet.
King's carries have been impressive and his work rate can't be questioned. He's doing the work of a forward which is what we really didn't get from Bibby (and weirdly, Isa and KPP when in that role). Sure, he's not created many tries for French but that seems to be more of a team issue. When he's got the chance to put French into the clear he has done, but it's not been as frequent this season. If we were creating the space but ignoring the opportunities I'd be more concerned about King, but we're not as fluid in attack down the right edge and that's as much to do with Cust, Isa/KPP and Field because they are the ones that need to create the space to create chances.
Re: Oliver gildart
I’d agree with much of the above. I don’t understand criticism of King so far. He had an iffy first game but has been one of our better players since. He’s eating ground up from our end and defensively has got better each week. That is likely down to him getting used to those around him. He’s different to Wardle on the other side, who is more of a classical centre but doesn’t get through half the work King does. I’m happy with the pair of them. They’re a huge upgrade on a pairing of Bibby and Thornley or Bibby and Isa (although granted, that wouldn’t be difficult).
-
- Posts: 3579
- Joined: Tue May 02, 2006 2:01 pm
Re: Oliver gildart
Relevant stats for King/Wardle:
Tries: 1/2
Try Assists: 3/3
Tackles: 68/49
Missed: 10/6
Busts: 14/14
Clean Breaks: 2/3
Carries: 82/54
Metres: 625/416
Dummy Runs: 8/1
Errors: 6/6
Offloads: 7/0
Pens conceded: 1/0
Tries: 1/2
Try Assists: 3/3
Tackles: 68/49
Missed: 10/6
Busts: 14/14
Clean Breaks: 2/3
Carries: 82/54
Metres: 625/416
Dummy Runs: 8/1
Errors: 6/6
Offloads: 7/0
Pens conceded: 1/0
Wigan 



Saints 


Re: Oliver gildart
Look evens going off those stats, I like both, think they’ll both get better but also think Wardle will reach another level.
Re: Oliver gildart
Is there similar stats available for our centres from this time last year?
Re: Oliver gildart
I think the stats back up what we see with our eyes. One is a workhorse and a good offloader and the other is more of a classical centre. They’re both settling nicely IMO.
-
- Posts: 5110
- Joined: Fri Sep 18, 2020 1:14 pm
Re: Oliver gildart
Simple question, what does Gilly give us that Wardle and King don’t?
Re: Oliver gildart
InjuriesCharriots Offiah wrote: ↑Mon Mar 20, 2023 8:03 pm Simple question, what does Gilly give us that Wardle and King don’t?
-
- Posts: 3579
- Joined: Tue May 02, 2006 2:01 pm
Re: Oliver gildart
JFTB? Over to you, Meds.Charriots Offiah wrote: ↑Mon Mar 20, 2023 8:03 pm Simple question, what does Gilly give us that Wardle and King don’t?
Wigan 



Saints 

