Page 11 of 13
Re: Josh Charnley
Posted: Wed Mar 23, 2016 12:23 am
by shaunedwardsfanclub
DaveO wrote:shaunedwardsfan​club​ wrote:
....I don't think he will ever recover his best form because he has lost pace.
Is there any real evidence of this? I haven't seen him given a clear run where pure pace was required once so far this season.
Just my view Dave. He had blistering pace a few years ago e.g. when he caught Shaul at Wembley, I have not seen any evidence of it in the last two campaigns but we shall see what this season brings. In my view he needs to lose some bulk. I hope he proves me wrong.
Re: Josh Charnley
Posted: Wed Mar 23, 2016 12:56 am
by medlocke
Panchitta Marra wrote:medlocke wrote:Panchitta Marra wrote:
Is Josh a Wigan player you don't rate meds?
He was ok a few seasons back, went off him last year with his
attitude problem, time for a change i reckon, get him swapped for Lachlan Maranta
Apart from goal kicking I think
mantellato has very little to offer Wigan or rugby league in general. He'd struggle to stand out in champs league 1 if he couldn't kick goals.
Not my cup of tea for a winger.
?????
Re: Josh Charnley
Posted: Wed Mar 23, 2016 6:57 am
by Owd Codger
medlocke wrote:Whelley Warrior wrote:cpwigan wrote:Never seen him play, any good
What, not even when he was with Goulding and gained International selection.
Sam Tomkins gifted him International selection, NOT Goulding
Not according to many others on here!
Re: Josh Charnley
Posted: Wed Mar 23, 2016 9:27 am
by medlocke
Whelley Warrior wrote:medlocke wrote:Whelley Warrior wrote:
What, not even when he was with Goulding and gained International selection.
Sam Tomkins gifted him International selection, NOT Goulding
Not according to many others on here!
Somebody posted stats of Tomkins and Goulding t'other day, Tomkins passing stats to Charnley where better than Gouldings, the end
Re: Josh Charnley
Posted: Wed Mar 23, 2016 9:36 am
by nathan_rugby
medlocke wrote:Whelley Warrior wrote:medlocke wrote:Sam Tomkins gifted him International selection, NOT Goulding
Not according to many others on here!
Somebody posted stats of Tomkins and Goulding t'other day, Tomkins passing stats to Charnley where better than Gouldings, the end
Goulding's tries and assists record was fanastic as well as his defence and partnership with Charnley.
Goulding in his Wigan prime was the best English centre and one of the most under rated players in the league.
Re: Josh Charnley
Posted: Wed Mar 23, 2016 5:26 pm
by Panchitta Marra
medlocke wrote:Panchitta Marra wrote:medlocke wrote:He was ok a few seasons back, went off him last year with his
attitude problem, time for a change i reckon, get him swapped for Lachlan Maranta
Apart from goal kicking I think
mantellato has very little to offer Wigan or rugby league in general. He'd struggle to stand out in champs league 1 if he couldn't kick goals.
Not my cup of tea for a winger.
?????
???????????????? thought you were taking the P meds, just realised Maranta is a winger, his first name put me off the trail. Duuuuggghhh.
Re: Josh Charnley
Posted: Tue Mar 29, 2016 4:45 pm
by chris1234
Charnley is signing for Sale this afternoon and sorting all the final bits of the deal out today im being told....
Re: Josh Charnley
Posted: Tue Mar 29, 2016 7:48 pm
by robspark
chris1234 wrote:Charnley is signing for Sale this afternoon and sorting all the final bits of the deal out today im being told....
if true, then Lenegan is very much a business man first and a wigan fan sadly second.
On current form Josh deserves a decent contract, which is presumably the root of the issue.
Re: Josh Charnley
Posted: Tue Mar 29, 2016 8:11 pm
by medlocke
robspark wrote:chris1234 wrote:Charnley is signing for Sale this afternoon and sorting all the final bits of the deal out today im being told....
if true, then Lenegan is very much a business man first and a wigan fan sadly second.
On current form Josh deserves a decent contract, which is presumably the root of the issue.
You've only just worked that one out
Re: Josh Charnley
Posted: Tue Mar 29, 2016 8:16 pm
by shaunedwardsfanclub
medlocke wrote:robspark wrote:chris1234 wrote:Charnley is signing for Sale this afternoon and sorting all the final bits of the deal out today im being told....
if true, then Lenegan is very much a business man first and a wigan fan sadly second.
On current form Josh deserves a decent contract, which is presumably the root of the issue.
That may be true Rob but who has their salary cut to pay for it?