Is that really worth a reply Cow Yeds.cow yeds wrote:How does a hooker nullify another hooker??Panchitta Marra wrote:Been saying the same about Mac for a while now.cpwigan wrote: Nowhere have I said Roby is not a good player BUT I am reminding people that he has been outplayed by Mac every time this season when they have faced each other. Yet we have some of our fans who seem to want to write Mac off for a sending off that our coach feels was unfair. Personally I can appreciate good / bad players from every team. KC was better than our hooker, better than Roby. Roby is an excellent player. James Graham was / is an excellent player BUT so is Micky Mac.
Ironically one of the posters rearing his head here wanted rid of Gaz Hock after he was sent off v Wire. This season never bad mouthed him once here albeit he has on RLfans. He frequently slated Lockers too. Now it seems Mac is his new whipping boy. Oddly he rates Rinaldi and Ah Van. I say no more.
Madge put Micky Mac on as first hooker in the 2010 Grand Final to nulify KFC, and I dare say MADGE got it right.
Mac now nulifies James Robey in the very same way.
In the Grand Final of 2010 Micky Mac nulified Keiran Cuningham by making him much less effective than what he wanted to be and what was maybe expected of him to be.
IMO Madge put MM on to do that job and he did.
Others on here might be able comment if my comments are correct or a load of bullshit.
From memory Cunningham was the first Saints hooker on for that game and so Madge put Micky Mac for that period of time and basically Cunningham was about as much use as a fart in an astronaughts suit in that game, all down to MM being in his face like a rash. Only my opinion of course.
Also from memory Cunningham went off, Robey came on and Madge swapped Mac for Tommy. Cunningham retired after that game.
Robey has yet to dominate Micky Mac in any Wigan v Saints match that I have seen, since Robey was introduced as their first choice hooker.
Maybe you can comment otherwise and let the good people on here decide.